# Phase 97 completion evidence

Generated by `scripts/verify-phase-97-completion.mjs`. “Activation required” means all locally actionable code, validation, and orchestration are complete, while the unchecked outcome requires external production data, credentials, model checkpoints, compute, simulation, or approval.

| Requirement | Status | Evidence | Activation / proof |
|---|---|---|---|
| 97.1.1.1 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/types.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.1.1.2 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/postgres.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/registry.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.1.1.3 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/discovery.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.1.1.4 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/semver.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/registry.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.1.1.5 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/dependencies.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.1.1.6 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/governance.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.1.1.7 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/skill-file.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.1.1.8 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/types.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.1.2.1 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/sandbox.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.1.2.2 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/execution.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.1.2.3 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/execution.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.1.2.4 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/execution.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/registry.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.1.2.5 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/execution.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.2.1.1 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/composition.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.2.1.2 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/composition.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.2.1.3 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/composition.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.2.1.4 | implemented | `apps/oshun/web/src/components/studio/skills/SkillSystemWorkspace.tsx`<br>`apps/oshun/web/e2e/skill-system-workspace.spec.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.2.1.5 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/pipeline-library.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.2.1.6 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/pipeline-library.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.2.1.7 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/agent-tree.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.2.2.1 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/domain-adapters.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/migration.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.2.2.2 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/domain-adapters.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/migration.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.2.2.3 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/registry.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/domain-adapters.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.2.2.4 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/domain-adapters.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.3.1.1 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/generation.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/source-scanner.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.3.1.2 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/generation.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/source-scanner.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.3.1.3 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/generation.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/source-scanner.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.3.1.4 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/generation.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/source-scanner.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.3.1.5 | activation-required | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/generation.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/training.ts` | Requires a trained model checkpoint and approved docstring-call training corpus; prompt/data interfaces are implemented. |
| 97.3.1.6 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/generation.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.3.2.1 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/evolution.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/generation.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.3.2.2 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/evolution.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/generation.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.3.2.3 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/evolution.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/generation.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.3.2.4 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/evolution.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/generation.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.3.2.5 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/evolution.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/generation.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.3.2.6 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/memento.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.3.3.1 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/evolution.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/memento.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.3.3.2 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/evolution.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/memento.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.3.3.3 | activation-required | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/evolution.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/training.ts` | RL policy training requires model compute; structured requests, semantic routing, generation fallback, and rewards are implemented. |
| 97.3.3.4 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/evolution.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/memento.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.3.3.5 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/evolution.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/memento.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.3.3.6 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/evolution.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.4.1.1 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/mcp.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.4.1.2 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/mcp.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.4.1.3 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/mcp.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.4.1.4 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/mcp.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.4.1.5 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/mcp.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.4.1.6 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/mcp.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.4.1.7 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/mcp.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.4.1.8 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/mcp.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.4.1.9 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/mcp.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.4.2.1 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/mcp.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.4.2.2 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/mcp.ts`<br>`apps/oshun/web/src/components/studio/skills/SkillSystemWorkspace.tsx` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.4.2.3 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/mcp.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.4.2.4 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/mcp.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.4.2.5 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/mcp.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.4.2.6 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/sandbox.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.5.1.1 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/quality.ts`<br>`apps/oshun/web/src/components/studio/skills/SkillSystemWorkspace.tsx` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.5.1.2 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/quality.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.5.1.3 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/quality.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.5.1.4 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/quality.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.5.1.5 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/quality.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.5.1.6 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/quality.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/memento.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.5.2.1 | activation-required | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/quality.ts` | Reward-model fitting requires rollout trajectories and training compute; trainer, Monte Carlo labels, hierarchy, and release gate are implemented. |
| 97.5.2.2 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/quality.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.5.2.3 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/quality.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.5.2.4 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/quality.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.6.1.1 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/training.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.6.1.2 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/training.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.6.1.3 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/training.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.6.1.4 | activation-required | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/training.ts` | xLAM fine-tuning requires Phase 89 model and Phase 87 dataset identifiers plus compute; executable job/backend/gate pipeline is implemented. |
| 97.6.1.5 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/training.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.6.1.6 | activation-required | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/training.ts` | RAFT fitting requires a model checkpoint and retrieved production corpus; example construction and training pipeline are implemented. |
| 97.6.2.1 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/training.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.6.2.2 | activation-required | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/training.ts` | Behavioral-cloning fitting requires consented large-scale demonstrations and compute; extraction and dataset pipelines are implemented. |
| 97.6.2.3 | activation-required | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/training.ts` | AutoTIR RL fitting requires an approved RL backend and compute; hybrid rewards and backend orchestration are implemented. |
| 97.6.2.4 | activation-required | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/training.ts` | Native skill-reasoning RL requires an approved self-hosted model/compute run; reward and release-gated orchestration are implemented. |
| 97.7.1.1 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/migration.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/evolution.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/training.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.7.1.2 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/migration.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/evolution.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/training.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.7.1.3 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/migration.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/evolution.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/training.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.7.1.4 | activation-required | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/migration.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/evolution.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/training.ts` | Iris production fine-tuning requires consented production calls, model checkpoint, and compute; collector, job, and benchmark gates are implemented. |
| 97.7.1.5 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/domain-enhancements.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.7.2.1 | activation-required | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/domain-enhancements.ts` | Publishing generated abilities requires real combat telemetry and an approved Maya simulation/deployment run; gap, generation, balance, and publish gates are implemented. |
| 97.7.2.2 | activation-required | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/domain-enhancements.ts` | Tutorial publication requires real player sequences and product approval; combo mining and statistical lift gates are implemented. |
| 97.7.2.3 | activation-required | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/domain-enhancements.ts` | Live NPC adaptation requires production observations and game deployment; bounded policy-learning logic is implemented. |
| 97.7.2.4 | activation-required | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/domain-enhancements.ts` | Reward deployment requires LLM candidates and Maya simulation results; evaluation and safe selection are implemented. |
| 97.7.3.1 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/domain-enhancements.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.7.3.2 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/domain-enhancements.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.7.3.3 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/domain-enhancements.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.7.4.1 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/domain-enhancements.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.7.4.2 | activation-required | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/domain-enhancements.ts` | Learned recommendations require production parameter/quality observations; bounded optimizer is implemented. |
| 97.7.4.3 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/domain-enhancements.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.7.5.1 | activation-required | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/domain-enhancements.ts` | Prompt improvement requires production article outcomes and editorial approval; scoring pipeline is implemented. |
| 97.7.5.2 | activation-required | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/domain-enhancements.ts` | Beat specialization requires production newsroom history; expertise estimator is implemented. |
| 97.7.5.3 | activation-required | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/domain-enhancements.ts` | Editorial transfer requires approved live performance evidence; reviewed transfer proposals are implemented. |
| 97.7.6.1 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/source-scanner.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/migration.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.7.6.2 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/source-scanner.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/migration.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.7.6.3 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/source-scanner.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/migration.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.7.6.4 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/source-scanner.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/migration.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.7.6.5 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/source-scanner.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/migration.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.7.6.6 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/source-scanner.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/migration.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.7.6.7 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/source-scanner.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/migration.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.7.6.8 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/source-scanner.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/migration.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.7.6.9 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/source-scanner.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/migration.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.7.6.10 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/source-scanner.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/migration.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.7.6.11 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/source-scanner.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/migration.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.7.6.12 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/source-scanner.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/migration.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.7.6.13 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/source-scanner.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/migration.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.7.6.14 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/source-scanner.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/migration.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.7.6.15 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/source-scanner.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/migration.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.7.6.16 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/source-scanner.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/migration.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.7.6.17 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/source-scanner.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/migration.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.7.6.18 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/source-scanner.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/migration.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.7.6.19 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/source-scanner.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/migration.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
| 97.7.6.20 | implemented | `libs/oshun/skill-system/src/source-scanner.ts`<br>`libs/oshun/skill-system/src/migration.ts` | Implemented and covered by repository verification. |
