# Appearance attributes, and what lighting does to them (2026-09-10)

Evidence for `182.C.19.02`, which names eight: face shape, complexion, age
presentation, hair, distinctive features, body proportions, wardrobe, and
permitted changes.

## Method

The committed frame
`../2026-09-10-openrouter-face-detection/two-foreground-subjects-plus-bystanders.png`
(1408×768, two foreground subjects and four bystanders), analysed with the
models already staged in `~/.cache/oshun-human-video`: YuNet for detection,
`face_landmarker.task` for geometry, `selfie_multiclass_256x256.tflite` for the
hair / face-skin / clothes segments, and `pose_landmarker_lite.task` for body
proportions.

Then the same frame through five real lighting variants — two white-balance
shifts (per-channel gain, which is what a colour temperature does to a camera)
and two one-stop exposure changes — plus a ten-point sweep of smaller changes.

## The finding: complexion is dominated by lighting

| Variant          | median lum | red gain | subject 0 L\* / ITA | subject 1 L\* / ITA |
| ---------------- | ---------- | -------- | ------------------- | ------------------- |
| reference        | 51.8       | 1.028    | 45.5 / **−11.6**    | 70.6 / **+52.1**    |
| warm ≈3200 K     | 53.7       | 1.195    | 49.0 / −1.6         | 74.1 / +34.6        |
| cool ≈7500 K     | 50.6       | 0.887    | 43.1 / −27.8        | 68.6 / +86.9        |
| exposure +1 stop | 94.9       | 1.017    | 82.7 / **+46.6**    | _not measurable_    |
| exposure −1 stop | 25.9       | 1.028    | 22.4 / −66.5        | 36.9 / −55.6        |

The two subjects differ by **63.7°** of Individual Typology Angle in the
reference frame — two visibly different people.

**A one-stop exposure change moves subject 0 by 58.2°.** Almost the entire
between-person gap, from nothing but the light. A modest white-balance shift
moves it 10.0°.

So a complexion comparison between two frames lit differently is a lighting
comparison wearing a complexion's name.

### How close does the lighting have to be

From the sweep:

| change        | param | Δ luminance | Δ red gain | subject 0 ΔITA | subject 1 ΔITA |
| ------------- | ----- | ----------- | ---------- | -------------- | -------------- |
| exposure      | −0.50 | −14.90      | 0.000      | −36.5          | −47.5          |
| exposure      | −0.25 | −8.24       | 0.000      | −20.6          | −16.6          |
| exposure      | −0.10 | −3.53       | 0.000      | −8.4           | −5.5           |
| exposure      | +0.10 | +3.14       | +0.001     | +7.2           | _n/a_          |
| white balance | 0.97  | −0.39       | −0.031     | −2.2           | +4.6           |
| white balance | 1.06  | +0.78       | +0.057     | +4.3           | −9.2           |

Slope: about **2.4° of ITA per unit of median luminance**, and 90–175° per unit
of grey-world red gain (the steeper subject sets the bound). Holding
lighting-induced drift near 5° means matching **luminance within 2** and **red
gain within 0.03** — and inside those bounds up to ~5° of any observed drift is
still the light, so a complexion finding has to clear it.

## Face shape survives lighting

| Variant          | width/height | jaw/width | interocular/width |
| ---------------- | ------------ | --------- | ----------------- |
| reference        | 0.78023      | 0.78055   | 0.66906           |
| warm ≈3200 K     | 0.78736      | 0.77909   | 0.66837           |
| cool ≈7500 K     | 0.77791      | 0.77961   | 0.67074           |
| exposure +1 stop | 0.78352      | 0.77957   | 0.66193           |
| exposure −1 stop | 0.79287      | 0.78407   | 0.66374           |

Width-over-height spans **1.92%**, jaw width 0.6%, interocular 1.3%. Geometry
survives light; colour does not, and that is why the two are gated differently.
The shipped constant carries 1.93 — rounded up, because understating a noise
floor is the direction that makes a gate fire on the light.

## Two more measured facts

**A measurement can disappear.** Subject 1's complexion was unavailable at +0.1,
+0.25 and +1.0 stops while present at +0.5. So "not measured in this frame" is
its own outcome and is never folded into "no change" — and the fact that
brightening costs coverage unevenly between subjects belongs to `182.C.19.09`.

**Small faces yield nothing, correctly.** Of six faces detected, only the two
foreground subjects (relative height 0.163 and 0.158) produced geometry or a
complexion. The four bystanders (0.033–0.068) produced neither: the landmarker
declined and the skin segment fell under the pixel floor. That matches the
`182.C.17` measurability floor.

## Two attributes are not measured at all

| Attribute            | Why                                                                                                                                                    |
| -------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ |
| age presentation     | No age model is staged, and estimating age from face geometry has a documented record of skewing by ethnicity. A number here would be worse than none. |
| distinctive features | Which scar, mole or tattoo matters is a per-subject declaration. Discovering them is a different and more invasive thing than checking a declared one. |

Both go to a person, always, and `assertHumanReviewComplete` refuses sign-off
while either is outstanding.

## Reproducing

```
python tools/human-video/evaluator/appearance_attributes.py \
  --image docs/domains/isis/human-video/evidence/2026-09-10-openrouter-face-detection/two-foreground-subjects-plus-bystanders.png
```

Note: analyse one image per process. Stacking MediaPipe task instances in a
single interpreter segfaults reproducibly after a handful, which is why the
lighting probe forks per image.

## Per-item status this evidence supports

| Item          | Was           | Is                                                                                                          |
| ------------- | ------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| `182.C.19.02` | `not-started` | done; five of seven attributes measured, two routed to human review, colour gated on matched lighting       |
| `182.C.19.08` | pending       | this is a second reason thresholds cannot be universal: the same cutoff means different things per lighting |
| `182.C.19.09` | pending       | brightening cost coverage unevenly between the two subjects — a fairness slice with a measurement behind it |
