Evidence for 182.C.07.03: detecting mixed identities in a reference pack
before any provider credit is spent. It extends
../2026-09-10-cpu-identity-embedding/,
which established that SFace runs on this box; this one commits the tool and
measures the pairs from a source image that is in the repository, so the numbers
regenerate.
Tool and models#
tools/human-video/face-embedding.py — YuNet
(face_detection_yunet_2023mar.onnx, 227 KB) locates the face and supplies the
five landmarks SFace aligns on; SFace (face_recognition_sface_2021dec.onnx,
38.7 MB) produces the 128-d embedding. Both OpenCV Zoo, Apache-2.0.
Measured cosines#
Source: the committed two-subject office photo. "Degraded" is that image through
boxblur=3:1, eq=brightness=0.12, and a 0.6× downscale-then-upscale — a stand
in for the generation-and-re-encode round trip an identity check has to survive.
| Pair | Cosine |
|---|---|
| Subject A vs subject B | 0.261 |
| Subject A vs A degraded | 0.739 |
| Subject B vs B degraded | 0.819 |
| Subject A vs B degraded | 0.177 |
| Subject B vs A degraded | 0.146 |
Raw: cosines.json. The embeddings themselves are not
committed — an embedding is derived from a real person's face and falls under
the same handling rules as the reference image (182.C.19.10). Cosines are
committed; vectors are not.
Why no threshold is set here#
On the same day, in the earlier probe, a different pair of strangers scored 0.422 — above the 0.35 identity gate inherited from ArcFace-oriented defaults. So this table's clean 0.26-against-0.74 separation is not a licence to pick a cutoff from it: five pairs from one photograph is not an ROC, and the one pair that would have broken the rule is not even in this table.
human-video-identity-consistency.ts therefore takes the calibration as an
input, refuses one fitted for a different model, and returns uncalibrated
rather than a verdict when none is bound. It also uses a two-sided band — same
person above, different below, uncertain in between routed to a human —
because a single cutoff is exactly what turned the 0.422 pair into an accept.
182.C.19.08 fits the real operating points on the corpus 182.C.33 gathers,
which is where fairness slices (182.C.19.09) get their say too; a cutoff
fitted on a generic public benchmark would be skewed in precisely the way that
item is about.
What this does not measure#
Two of the four detections 182.C.07.03 names are not delivered, and the
module returns them as not-measured findings with their reason attached rather
than leaving them silent:
- Face swaps. No manipulation detector is available on this stack. An uncalibrated deepfake score would invite belief it has not earned.
- Age mismatches. No age estimator is available. The character pack carries
a declared
apparent-age-band(182.C.07.01), but nothing here measures the age a reference reads as, so a declared band cannot be checked against one.
Reference contradictions, the fourth detection, need no model at all and are
delivered: references naming two different subjects, one image submitted under
two roles, a face-angle reference that is front-on, and a full-body
reference whose measured frame stops above the ankles.