Evidence for 182.C.19, and the second correction of the day. All ten
182.C.19 rows carried the same blocker text — "No GPU host; needs a RunPod
worker per 182.C.17.13" — applied uniformly. That blanket claim was wrong, and
I repeated it in conversation before testing it.
The central premise was false#
The stated reason 182.C.19 could not proceed was that no CPU model here
produces an ArcFace-class embedding. SFace does, it is in the same OpenCV
Zoo as the YuNet detector, it is Apache-2.0, and cv2.FaceRecognizerSF runs
it on CPU.
Measured, 128-d embeddings, cosine similarity:
| Pair | Cosine |
|---|---|
| Reference person vs itself, degraded | 0.802 |
| Reference person vs other woman #1 | 0.269 |
| Reference person vs other woman #2 | 0.422 |
| Other woman #1 vs other woman #2 | 0.261 |
"Degraded" is the reference put through boxblur=3:1, brightness=+0.12, and a
0.6× downscale-then-upscale — standing in for the generation-and-re-encode round
trip an identity gate actually has to survive. It survives it: 0.802 against
0.26–0.42 for strangers.
So identity similarity is computable on this machine today.
And it immediately found a threshold defect#
182.C.03.05 C4 gates identity at cosine ≥ 0.35, a value inherited from the
ArcFace-oriented defaults in
libs/nous/portrait-animation/src/portrait-animation-quality-metrics-pipeline.ts
and carried into quality-policy.ts as minIdentityCosine.
Under SFace, two different people scored 0.422 — a false accept, comfortably above that gate. SFace's own published operating point is ~0.363, which this pair also clears.
This is not a reason to distrust the embedding; it is a reason the inherited
number cannot be used. A threshold is only meaningful paired with the model that
produced it, and the "these are a starting point, not a calibration — 182.C.34
re-fits them" caveat written into quality-policy.ts is now demonstrated rather
than asserted. Whatever model ships, C4's cutoff has to come from a measured ROC
on our own corpus, and it has to be per-model.
Per-item status, replacing the blanket blocker#
| Item | Real status |
|---|---|
.01 identity similarity + temporal drift |
Not blocked. SFace supplies the embeddings; libs/isis/workflows/src/consistency/identity-drift.ts already computes cosine and drift over supplied vectors (02.04). The missing piece was exactly the extractor. |
.02 face shape, complexion, age, hair, wardrobe |
Needs attribute models plus human review. Not GPU-blocked; model-and-corpus work. |
.03 track through profile turns, cuts, multiple people |
Not blocked. Per-frame detect + embed + assignment is CPU-feasible; cost is time, not capability. |
.04 face merging, swaps, duplicates, flicker |
Not blocked. Derivable from per-frame embeddings and boxes. |
.05 malformed teeth/jaw, extra limbs, fused props |
Genuinely blocked on models — no anatomy/artifact detector here, and this is not something a face model provides. |
.06 motion smoothness, optical flow, freeze, judder |
Not blocked. ffmpeg has freezedetect; cv2 has Farneback optical flow. |
.07 camera/control adherence, gaze, emotion, action completion |
Partially reachable, weakly measurable. Needs care to avoid VLM judgement dressed as measurement. |
.08 calibrate thresholds by visibility and shot size |
Blocked on a corpus, not on hardware — and the 0.422 false accept above shows why it matters. |
.09 fairness slices |
Blocked on a labelled corpus with demographic slices, gathered with consent. Compute does not solve this one, and it is the hardest of the ten. |
.10 store embeddings with encryption, tenant isolation, deletion linkage, audit |
Never blocked at all. Pure storage and access engineering. |
Four are unblocked, one was never blocked, three need corpora or attribute
models, and one (.05) is genuinely blocked on models this box does not have.
None of the ten is blocked for the stated reason.
Why the wrong blocker persisted#
It was inherited rather than tested. The phase constraints describe a 16 GB
MacBook Air on which "SyncNet-class evaluators, face tracking, and ASR are
hardware-blocked locally"; that sentence became a row-level status for ten items
without any of them being tried. This worktree is Linux with 15 GiB and 4 cores,
onnxruntime was already installed, and both models needed are Apache-2.0 and
under 40 MB.
The rule this suggests: blocked-local must name what was attempted and what
failed. A blocker copied across ten rows is a claim about none of them.
Licensing#
Both models are Apache-2.0 — YuNet (227 KB) and SFace (38.7 MB), OpenCV Zoo.
That matters for 182.C.02.06, which flagged the insightface weights in
apps/psyche/avatar-engine as carrying non-commercial terms. The commercially
usable path does not run through those weights.