# Frame artifacts: one detector, four disqualifications (2026-09-10)

Evidence for `182.C.19.05`, which names seven artifacts: malformed
teeth/tongue/lips, jaw discontinuity, asymmetry spikes, face boundary tearing,
extra limbs/digits, fused props, and impossible object contact.

**One of the seven is now detected. Four candidate approaches were measured and
all four failed**, and the failures are the more useful half of this page —
somebody will otherwise build them again.

## Fixture

The committed three-panel probe
`../2026-09-10-face-mesh-artifact-probe/clean-vs-doubled-mouth-vs-tear.png`: the
same real face, clean, with a **doubled mouth**, and with a horizontal band
displaced (**boundary tearing**). A fourth panel, a vertical tear, is built from
the clean one the same way, to validate the column axis against a fault known to
be there.

## What works: line continuity

A tear is a **displacement** — a band shifted, so at its edges one row no longer
continues into the next. Correlation between adjacent rows measures exactly
that.

| Panel             | worst row corr | rows < 0.7 | worst col corr | cols < 0.7 |
| ----------------- | -------------- | ---------- | -------------- | ---------- |
| clean             | 0.796          | 0          | 0.810          | 0          |
| doubled mouth     | 0.796          | 0          | 0.810          | 0          |
| torn (horizontal) | **0.292**      | **2**      | 0.833          | 0          |
| torn (vertical)   | 0.558          | 1          | **0.224**      | **2**      |

It also names _where_: row 168 for the horizontal tear and column 170 for the
vertical one, both the displaced band's edge. And the axis with the lower
minimum names the tear's orientation — a vertical tear disturbs some rows too
(0.558), but far less than it disturbs columns.

A 0.7 threshold sits between 0.796 and 0.292 with room on both sides. Two
discontinuous lines are required rather than one, because a displaced band has
two edges and a single bad line is as likely to be a hard cut inside the frame —
a title card edge, a split screen.

## What does not work

### Segmentation consistency — the item's own suggested candidate

| Panel         | face-skin components | largest share | holes | boundary roughness |
| ------------- | -------------------- | ------------- | ----- | ------------------ |
| clean         | 2 (1 over 100 px)    | 1.000         | 0     | 19.28              |
| doubled mouth | 1                    | 1.000         | 0     | 20.26              |
| torn          | 1                    | 1.000         | 0     | 25.63              |

Every structural measure is identical. Roughness moves 33% for the tear and only
5% for the doubled mouth — inside the difference between two ordinary frames.

### Copy-move block matching

The idea that a doubled mouth is a pasted copy. 24×24 blocks, stride 8, flat
blocks skipped, pairs at least 40 px apart:

| Panel         | best distant correlation | best pair             | pairs > 0.99 |
| ------------- | ------------------------ | --------------------- | ------------ |
| clean         | 0.9709                   | (140,156) ↔ (188,260) | 0            |
| doubled mouth | 0.9709                   | (140,156) ↔ (188,260) | 0            |
| torn          | 0.9707                   | (140,156) ↔ (188,260) | 0            |

Identical on all three, on the same coordinate pair. The doubled mouth is not a
pixel copy, so block matching cannot see it.

### Dense face-mesh asymmetry and lip curvature

Disqualified earlier the same day in `../2026-09-10-face-mesh-artifact-probe/`:
the mesh scored the **doubled mouth as more regular than the clean face**.

## Still undetected

| Artifact                               | Status                                                                                      |
| -------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| malformed teeth/tongue/lips            | four approaches measured and failed; remaining candidate is a trained detector (`182.C.33`) |
| jaw discontinuity                      | no fixture; a hard displacement would show here, a soft malformation would not              |
| asymmetry spikes                       | mesh asymmetry disqualified                                                                 |
| extra limbs/digits                     | hand keypoint models emit 21 keypoints unconditionally                                      |
| fused props, impossible object contact | needs scene understanding, which nothing staged here provides                               |

## Reproducing

```
python tools/human-video/evaluator/frame_continuity.py --image <frame.png>
```

## Per-item status this evidence supports

| Item          | Was           | Is                                                                                             |
| ------------- | ------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| `182.C.19.05` | `not-started` | `blocked-corpus`: 1 of 7 detected, 4 approaches disqualified, malformed mouth needs `182.C.33` |
