# Why one cutoff cannot work (2026-09-10)

Evidence for `182.C.19.08`: calibrate identity and artifact thresholds by
visibility, shot size, motion blur and stylization rather than one universal
cutoff, per embedding model.

Fitting the **operating point** needs the labelled corpus `182.C.33` gathers,
and that is still true — this item stays unchecked. What does **not** need it,
and is measured here, is how far each condition **moves** the score. That is the
part that makes a corpus usable: whatever cutoff the labels give has to be
adjusted by these amounts, and under some conditions no cutoff exists at all.

## Method

One real face from the committed frame, embedded with SFace, then measured
**against itself** under each condition with the model and framing fixed. Two
different people from the same frame give the scale.

**Two different people score 0.2817.**

Margin below is the self-cosine minus that fixed baseline; "retained" is that
margin as a fraction of the clean 0.718.

| Condition                        | self-cosine | margin     | retained |
| -------------------------------- | ----------- | ---------- | -------- |
| clean                            | 1.000       | 0.718      | 100%     |
| lighting, −1 stop                | 0.960       | 0.679      | 95%      |
| lighting, +1 stop                | 0.830       | 0.549      | 76%      |
| shot size, face 14% of frame     | 0.927       | 0.645      | 90%      |
| shot size, face 8%               | 0.852       | 0.570      | 79%      |
| shot size, face 5.6%             | 0.718       | 0.436      | 61%      |
| shot size, face 4.4%             | 0.451       | 0.169      | 24%      |
| motion blur, 5 px                | 0.906       | 0.624      | 87%      |
| motion blur, 11 px               | 0.679       | 0.397      | 55%      |
| motion blur, 21 px               | 0.313       | 0.031      | **4%**   |
| **motion blur, 31 px**           | **0.251**   | **−0.031** | **−4%**  |
| stylization, grayscale           | 0.916       | 0.635      | 88%      |
| stylization, bilateral           | 0.756       | 0.474      | 66%      |
| stylization, posterize           | 0.624       | 0.342      | 48%      |
| **stylization, edge-preserving** | **0.267**   | **−0.014** | **−2%**  |

## The finding

**Two conditions put a face below the different-person baseline against
itself.** At 31 pixels of motion blur, and under an edge-preserving stylization,
a person's own face resembles itself _less_ than two strangers resemble each
other.

No cutoff separates those cases, because there is nothing left to separate: a
threshold low enough to admit the blurred self-match admits every stranger too.
That is not "the threshold is not yet fitted" — it is "the decision is
impossible", and `assertDecidable` refuses rather than returning one.

Conditions do not compensate, either. A face at 31 px of blur is undecidable
however well lit it is, so the **worst** condition present governs.

Lighting is the mild one here — 76% retained at a full stop — which is worth
saying because `182.C.19.03` measured a lighting _ramp_ costing 0.25 of cosine.
The difference is that the ramp compounded with framing change across a
sequence; a stop of exposure on a fixed framing does not.

## Adjusting a fitted point

`adjustForConditions` pulls a fitted operating point toward the baseline by the
measured retention. It **refuses a base that was never fitted on labels** —
scaling an unfitted number by a measured factor produces a number that looks
calibrated and is not, which is exactly what the inherited 0.35 gate was when
SFace put two strangers at 0.422.

## The case against one universal cutoff

Five independent measurements, each with its own evidence directory, carried in
code so a reader asked to accept per-condition calibration can see why:

1. Two strangers at **0.422** under SFace against a 0.35 inherited gate —
   `evidence/2026-09-10-cpu-identity-embedding/`
2. A lighting ramp costing **0.25 of cosine** on a held identity —
   `evidence/2026-09-10-identity-tracking/`
3. Blur leaving the detector **0.879 confident** while the embedding fell to a
   self-cosine of **0.033** — `evidence/2026-09-10-visual-integrity/`
4. One stop of exposure moving skin-tone ITA by **58°** —
   `evidence/2026-09-10-appearance-attributes/`
5. A face **below the different-person baseline against itself** under blur and
   stylization — this directory.

## Per-item status this evidence supports

| Item          | Was           | Is                                                                                                       |
| ------------- | ------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| `182.C.19.08` | `not-started` | `blocked-corpus`: per-condition margins measured and shipped; the operating point still needs `182.C.33` |
