# Visual integrity faults, measured (2026-09-10)

Evidence for `182.C.19.04`: face merging, identity swaps, duplicate people,
flicker, sudden age/skin-tone shifts, and a speaker inheriting another person's
mouth or voice.

Real face crops from the committed frame
`../2026-09-10-openrouter-face-detection/two-foreground-subjects-plus-bystanders.png`,
alpha-blended, duplicated, blurred and tone-shifted, all measured with YuNet
detection and SFace embeddings.

## The finding that matters most is not one of the six

**Blur destroys identity long before it destroys detection.**

| Gaussian σ | detected? | confidence | cosine against its own unblurred self |
| ---------- | --------- | ---------- | ------------------------------------- |
| 0          | yes       | 0.938      | 0.866                                 |
| 4          | yes       | 0.922      | 0.453                                 |
| 8          | yes       | **0.879**  | **0.033** — random                    |
| 12         | yes       | **0.792**  | **−0.103** — negatively correlated    |
| 16         | no        | —          | —                                     |

At σ=8 the detector is 0.879 confident there is a face, and that face's
embedding has collapsed to noise. A pipeline that gates on detection score will
feed noise into identity comparison and get a confident wrong answer.
`assertEmbeddingUsable` runs before any of the six detections, because every one
of them reads an embedding.

## The signatures

### Face merging

| alpha | cos(A) | cos(B) | margin |
| ----- | ------ | ------ | ------ |
| 0.00  | 0.882  | 0.251  | 0.631  |
| 0.25  | 0.688  | 0.238  | 0.450  |
| 0.50  | 0.341  | 0.320  | 0.021  |
| 0.75  | 0.257  | 0.703  | 0.446  |
| 1.00  | 0.210  | 0.828  | 0.618  |

A 50/50 blend of two real faces embeds as **neither person, and equally unlike
both**. The signature is a low best cosine **and** a near-zero margin — both, in
conjunction. A low cosine alone is an unknown face; a small margin alone is two
strangers who look alike.

### Duplicate people

The same crop twice in one frame gives two simultaneous detections at mutual
cosine **0.9565**; two different people side by side give **0.3243**.
Simultaneity is what makes it a fault: the same person across two frames is the
point of tracking, and the same person twice in _one_ frame is impossible.

### Flicker

Reproduced at the detection boundary — blur alternating σ 12 (detected, 0.792
confident) and σ 16 (not detected) flipped presence on **11 of 11** transitions.

It did **not** reproduce by size: YuNet held a detection down to a 16-pixel face
and never dropped one oscillating between 56- and 40-pixel patches. So flicker
here is a marginal-**quality** phenomenon, not a marginal-size one.

### Sudden skin-tone shift

An ITA move of **+40.9°** under constant lighting left the identity cosine at
**0.954**. SFace is essentially blind to skin tone, so an identity check will
**not** catch a tone change. They are independent detections and both are needed
— and a tone comparison across mismatched lighting is refused, because
`182.C.19.02` measured a one-stop exposure change moving a subject 58.2°.

### Identity swaps

Measured under `182.C.19.03`: occlusion swapped a track onto the other person
twice. See `../2026-09-10-identity-tracking/`.

### A speaker inheriting another person's mouth or voice

Split, honestly. The **mouth** half is measurable and already built —
`human-video-speaker-binding.ts` (`182.C.17`) binds speech runs to mouth motion
and detects a face moving its mouth while somebody else speaks. The **voice**
half needs speaker embeddings or diarisation, which is not staged on this box,
so it is reported as not-measured rather than approximated.

## Not measured at all

| Fault           | Why                                                                                        |
| --------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ |
| age shift       | No age model is staged; `182.C.19.02` records why a number would be worse than none.       |
| inherited voice | Needs speaker embeddings or diarisation. The mouth half is covered; the voice half is not. |

Both travel in the report rather than in a comment, because a report listing
clean detections reads as clean whether or not two more were never attempted.

## Per-item status this evidence supports

| Item          | Was           | Is                                                                                      |
| ------------- | ------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| `182.C.19.04` | `not-started` | done for five of six; age shift and the voice half of the sixth are not measured        |
| `182.C.19.08` | pending       | a fourth reason a universal cutoff cannot work: image quality moves the cosine to noise |
