# Availability differs per subject (2026-09-11)

Evidence for `182.C.19.09`: fairness slices for dark skin, varied lighting,
facial hair, head coverings, makeup, glasses, age, and disability-related facial
or motor differences.

**Populating the slices needs subjects, which is `182.C.33`, so this item stays
unchecked.** What is built is the machinery that makes a corpus report anything
useful — and one measurement showing why the machinery has to exist.

## Method

Two subjects from the committed frame, differing by **63.7° of Individual
Typology Angle**, through nine exposure levels from −2 to +2 stops.

| stops | median lum | s0 detected | s0 shape | s0 complexion | s1 detected | s1 shape | s1 complexion |
| ----- | ---------- | ----------- | -------- | ------------- | ----------- | -------- | ------------- |
| −2.0  | 11.4       | ✓           | ✓        | ✓             | ✓           | ✓        | ✓             |
| −1.5  | 17.6       | ✓           | ✓        | ✓             | ✓           | ✓        | ✓             |
| −1.0  | 25.9       | ✓           | ✓        | ✓             | ✓           | ✓        | **✗**         |
| −0.5  | 36.9       | ✓           | ✓        | ✓             | ✓           | ✓        | ✓             |
| 0.0   | 51.8       | ✓           | ✓        | ✓             | ✓           | ✓        | ✓             |
| +0.5  | 71.0       | ✓           | ✓        | ✓             | ✓           | ✓        | ✓             |
| +1.0  | 94.9       | ✓           | ✓        | ✓             | ✓           | ✓        | **✗**         |
| +1.5  | 100.0      | ✓           | ✓        | ✓             | ✓           | ✓        | **✗**         |
| +2.0  | 100.0      | ✓           | ✓        | **✗**         | ✓           | ✓        | **✗**         |

|                       | detected | face shape | **complexion** |
| --------------------- | -------- | ---------- | -------------- |
| subject 0 (ITA −11.6) | 9/9      | 9/9        | **8/9**        |
| subject 1 (ITA +52.1) | 9/9      | 9/9        | **5/9**        |

## The finding

Both subjects were **detected** in every condition and both had their face
**geometry** measured in every condition. What differed was the **complexion**
measurement, which depends on the face-skin segment having enough pixels: the
lighter-complexioned subject lost it in four conditions and the darker one in
one.

**Aggregate numbers hide this.** Pooled, the complexion measurement succeeded 13
of 18 times — **72%**, a number that describes neither subject (they were 89%
and 56%). An aggregate is the shape a fairness fault hides in, and
`assertSliced` refuses one that carries no slices.

**Availability is the thing to slice, not just accuracy.** Every gate in this
phase distinguishes "measured and passed" from "not measurable", so a subject
whose attribute is more often unmeasurable gets _less_ scrutiny, not more. That
is a fairness fault with no wrong answer in it anywhere, and it would be
invisible to any report that only tracked pass rates.

**The direction was not the expected one.** The commonly-cited failure is dark
skin under-detected in low light. Here the _lighter_ subject lost more
measurements, under _brightening_.

## This is not a fairness evaluation

**Two subjects.** This establishes that per-subject availability differs and
nothing whatsoever about a population. `SEED_OBSERVATION.isFairnessEvaluation`
is `false` in code, and `MIN_SUBJECTS_PER_BUCKET` is 30 — deliberately larger
than anything currently available, so no bucket is powered today and
`assertBucketPowered` refuses a rate from any of them.

What the two subjects do prove is that assuming the direction would have been
wrong on this pair.

## What the machinery does

- Eight slices, each with buckets and a note on why it matters here. Skin tone
  and lighting are **measured**; the rest are **declared** — a facial-hair or
  makeup classifier would be a second uncalibrated model, and age is declared
  and never estimated for the reason `182.C.19.02` records.
- Facial or motor differences are declared **by the subject and by nobody
  else**, and the note says why the slice matters: every artifact detector in
  this phase treats asymmetry and irregular motion as faults.
- `availability` and `passRateWhereMeasured` are reported apart. A bucket where
  nothing could be measured has a pass rate of nothing-over-nothing, which
  prints as a blank or a 100% depending on who wrote the formatter.
- A report is never `complete` while any slice is missing **or** has no powered
  bucket. A report of clean slices, none of them powered, is a report of nothing
  having been measured.

## Per-item status this evidence supports

| Item          | Was           | Is                                                                                        |
| ------------- | ------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| `182.C.19.09` | `not-started` | `blocked-corpus`: slice machinery built and the availability gap measured on two subjects |
