Measured 2026-09-11 on the Linux dev server, ffmpeg 6.1.1-3ubuntu5. Reproduce
with bash measure.sh <outdir>; raw output in results.json.
The matrix#
Two independent questions, and the combination is what decides the verdict.
| Operation | Manifest survives transport | Digest unchanged | Verdict |
|---|---|---|---|
| trim | yes | no | survives but invalid |
| concat | no | no | silently lost |
| mux (demux + remux) | yes | yes | valid |
| transcode | yes | no | survives but invalid |
| caption burn-in | yes | no | survives but invalid |
| thumbnail | no | no | silently lost |
One of six operations preserves provenance, and it is the one that changes nothing: demuxing and remuxing the same streams reproduced a byte-identical file.
The two ways it goes wrong#
Survives but invalid (trim, transcode, burn-in). The manifest travels and
binds bytes that no longer exist, so a verifier reports a hash mismatch — the
same answer it gives for a maliciously edited file. 182.C.28.03 measured this
for transcode; it holds for trim and burn-in too.
Silently lost (concat, thumbnail). No manifest at all, which reads as "this asset never had provenance" rather than "provenance was destroyed here".
Concat is the worse of the two, because concat is the operation where provenance
matters most: it joins material from different sources, and the output of
joining an authorized clip to an unauthorized one carries no claim about either.
-map_metadata 0 does not recover it — measured, not assumed; the concat
demuxer drops it regardless.
Thumbnail is the one that is easy to forget. A still frame of a synthetic person is a picture of a face, and as a PNG it carries no manifest and no synthetic-media disclosure. A thumbnail posted on its own is an undisclosed synthetic image of a person.
What follows#
Every one of the six needs the manifest reissued over the new bytes, and two of them need it re-attached from scratch because nothing arrives to reissue. A pipeline that reissues only after a transcode leaves concat and thumbnail with no provenance at all.