# ISIS v2 VFX Element Pack Canonical Requirements Brief

Generated: 2026-08-02T18:33:40.718Z Checklist: `MXA-0415` (ISIS2-00613) Asset
Family: `vfx-element-pack` Phase: Phase 4 | Milestone: M3 Launch (2026-07-27 to
2026-10-30)

## Objective

Define a canonical implementation contract for `vfx-element-pack` so workflow
design, contract exposure, operational rollout, and quality certification
execute with measurable, release-gated criteria.

## Scope

### In Scope

- Workflow family requirements spanning baseline, conditioned, and
  consistency-locked variants.
- Control, consistency, output package, and surface parity requirements for
  element contour stability, alpha compositing readiness, and temporal
  coherence.
- Success metrics and explicit failure criteria tied to Matrix A delivery
  tickets.

### Out of Scope

- Implementation details for non-vfx-element asset families.
- Provider-specific low-level node wiring beyond declared dependency/control
  contracts.

## Baseline Assessment

- Related baseline workflow count: 5
- Missing required controls in related baseline: ipadapter-style,
  ipadapter-composition
- Current control-mode pass rate (global baseline): 81.58%
- Current required control quality average (selected controls): 0.975

### Existing Related Workflows

| Workflow ID              | Asset Family                    | Output Profile          | Controls                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                   |
| ------------------------ | ------------------------------- | ----------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ |
| `3d-texture`             | `game-pbr-texture-material-set` | `game-ready-3d-profile` | camera-lock, color-script-lock, controlnet-depth, controlnet-normal, controlnet-tile, depth-constraint, identity-adapter, latent-reuse, model-lock, palette-lock, pose-constraint, prompt-template-lock, reference-ensemble, sampler-scheduler-lock, scene-lock, seed-lock, style-anchor, style-lock, temporal-lock, wardrobe-lock                                                                                                                                                                                                         |
| `animatediff-controlnet` | `film-previs-blocking-reel`     | `video-master-profile`  | camera-lock, camera-path-guide, color-script-lock, controlnet-canny, controlnet-depth, controlnet-lineart, controlnet-normal, controlnet-pose, controlnet-scribble, controlnet-segmentation, controlnet-softedge, depth-constraint, identity-adapter, identity-lock, keyframe-anchor-lock, latent-reuse, model-lock, motion-vector-lock, openpose-sequence, palette-lock, pose-constraint, prompt-template-lock, reference-ensemble, sampler-scheduler-lock, scene-lock, seed-lock, style-anchor, style-lock, temporal-lock, wardrobe-lock |
| `environment-map`        | `game-skybox-hdri-pack`         | `game-ready-3d-profile` | camera-lock, color-script-lock, controlnet-depth, depth-constraint, identity-adapter, latent-reuse, lens-profile-lock, model-lock, palette-lock, pose-constraint, prompt-template-lock, reference-ensemble, sampler-scheduler-lock, scene-lock, seed-lock, style-anchor, style-lock, temporal-lock, wardrobe-lock                                                                                                                                                                                                                          |
| `mandala-3d`             | `game-pbr-texture-material-set` | `game-ready-3d-profile` | camera-lock, color-script-lock, controlnet-depth, controlnet-normal, controlnet-tile, depth-constraint, identity-adapter, latent-reuse, lens-profile-lock, model-lock, palette-lock, pose-constraint, prompt-template-lock, reference-ensemble, sampler-scheduler-lock, scene-lock, seed-lock, style-anchor, style-lock, temporal-lock, wardrobe-lock                                                                                                                                                                                      |
| `sfx-sound-designer`     | `film-vfx-element-library`      | `audio-master-profile`  | camera-lock, color-script-lock, depth-constraint, identity-adapter, latent-reuse, model-lock, palette-lock, pose-constraint, prompt-template-lock, reference-ensemble, sampler-scheduler-lock, scene-lock, seed-lock, style-anchor, style-lock, temporal-lock, wardrobe-lock                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                               |

## Canonical Requirements

### Output Package Contract Baseline

| Output Class        | Required Package Classes                |
| ------------------- | --------------------------------------- |
| `preview_image`     | `preview`, `metadata`, `manifest`       |
| `source_frames`     | `source-frames`, `metadata`, `manifest` |
| `metadata_manifest` | `metadata`, `manifest`                  |

### Required Controls

| Control                   | Category           | Coverage Baseline | Quality Baseline |
| ------------------------- | ------------------ | ----------------- | ---------------- |
| `seed-lock`               | determinism        | 5 workflows       | 1.000            |
| `sampler-scheduler-lock`  | determinism        | 5 workflows       | 1.000            |
| `model-lock`              | determinism        | 5 workflows       | 1.000            |
| `prompt-template-lock`    | determinism        | 5 workflows       | 1.000            |
| `style-lock`              | style-and-identity | 5 workflows       | 1.000            |
| `color-script-lock`       | style-and-identity | 5 workflows       | 1.000            |
| `ipadapter-style`         | reference-guidance | 0 workflows       | 0.900            |
| `ipadapter-composition`   | reference-guidance | 0 workflows       | 0.900            |
| `controlnet-pose`         | spatial-guidance   | 1 workflows       | 1.000            |
| `controlnet-depth`        | spatial-guidance   | 4 workflows       | 1.000            |
| `controlnet-segmentation` | spatial-guidance   | 1 workflows       | 1.000            |
| `controlnet-normal`       | spatial-guidance   | 3 workflows       | 1.000            |
| `controlnet-canny`        | spatial-guidance   | 1 workflows       | 0.950            |
| `controlnet-lineart`      | spatial-guidance   | 1 workflows       | 0.950            |
| `lens-profile-lock`       | camera-and-motion  | 2 workflows       | 0.925            |

### Functional Requirements

| ID      | Checklist  | Requirement                                                                                                                                             |
| ------- | ---------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| `F-000` | `MXA-0415` | Publish a canonical, machine-readable requirements brief for `vfx-element-pack` that defines scope, constraints, success metrics, and failure criteria. |
| `F-001` | `MXA-0416` | Design baseline workflow graph for `vfx-element-pack` with deterministic defaults.                                                                      |
| `F-002` | `MXA-0417` | Design image-conditioned variant workflow for `vfx-element-pack`.                                                                                       |
| `F-003` | `MXA-0418` | Design control-conditioned variant workflow for `vfx-element-pack` (pose/depth/segmentation where applicable).                                          |
| `F-004` | `MXA-0419` | Design consistency-locked variant workflow for `vfx-element-pack` with continuity profile support.                                                      |
| `F-005` | `MXA-0420` | Define model/node dependency manifest for `vfx-element-pack` workflows.                                                                                 |
| `F-006` | `MXA-0421` | Define output package contract for `vfx-element-pack` including file naming and metadata manifest.                                                      |
| `F-007` | `MXA-0422` | Add workflow templates and presets for `vfx-element-pack` production tiers (draft/final/hero).                                                          |
| `F-008` | `MXA-0423` | Expose `vfx-element-pack` workflows via generation API with typed request contracts.                                                                    |
| `F-009` | `MXA-0424` | Expose `vfx-element-pack` workflows via SDK with end-to-end examples.                                                                                   |
| `F-010` | `MXA-0425` | Expose `vfx-element-pack` workflows in web UI with ergonomic form controls and validation.                                                              |
| `F-011` | `MXA-0426` | Implement side-by-side comparison tools for `vfx-element-pack` outputs.                                                                                 |
| `F-012` | `MXA-0427` | Map `vfx-element-pack` workflows to RunPod endpoint classes and sizing policies.                                                                        |
| `F-013` | `MXA-0428` | Add `vfx-element-pack` cost estimation and budget guardrails.                                                                                           |
| `F-014` | `MXA-0429` | Add `vfx-element-pack` quality evaluator and threshold-based acceptance gate.                                                                           |
| `F-015` | `MXA-0430` | Add `vfx-element-pack` regression tests and golden datasets.                                                                                            |
| `F-016` | `MXA-0431` | Add `vfx-element-pack` external integration recipe for downstream tools/systems.                                                                        |
| `F-017` | `MXA-0432` | Publish `vfx-element-pack` operator and creator documentation with troubleshooting.                                                                     |

### Non-Functional Requirements

| ID       | Title                            | Verification                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                       |
| -------- | -------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| `NF-001` | Deterministic replay reliability | Replay the approved golden set over two independent runs and compute reproducibility pass ratio.                                                                                                                                                                                   |
| `NF-002` | Control coverage completeness    | Run contract and UX coverage checks against control IDs: seed-lock, style-lock, color-script-lock, ipadapter-style, ipadapter-composition, controlnet-pose, controlnet-depth, controlnet-segmentation, controlnet-normal, controlnet-canny, controlnet-lineart, lens-profile-lock. |
| `NF-003` | Output package integrity         | Validate output package contract and checksum manifest presence for each golden output.                                                                                                                                                                                            |
| `NF-004` | Operational budget guardrails    | Evaluate p95 runtime/cost telemetry against policy thresholds and enforce rejection when guardrails fail.                                                                                                                                                                          |
| `NF-005` | External integration readiness   | Pass external integration cookbook examples and operator runbook smoke checks.                                                                                                                                                                                                     |

## Success Metrics

| Metric   | Target                                                                                                                           | Baseline                                                                      | Linked Checklist IDs                                                                                                                                                                                       |
| -------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| `SM-001` | >= 4 certified workflows (baseline, image-conditioned, control-conditioned, consistency-locked).                                 | 0 workflows currently mapped to `vfx-element-pack`.                           | `MXA-0416`, `MXA-0417`, `MXA-0418`, `MXA-0419`, `MXA-0430`                                                                                                                                                 |
| `SM-002` | 17/17 downstream tickets DONE by milestone end date.                                                                             | 17/17 downstream tickets are DONE at report generation.                       | `MXA-0416`, `MXA-0417`, `MXA-0418`, `MXA-0419`, `MXA-0420`, `MXA-0421`, `MXA-0422`, `MXA-0423`, `MXA-0424`, `MXA-0425`, `MXA-0426`, `MXA-0427`, `MXA-0428`, `MXA-0429`, `MXA-0430`, `MXA-0431`, `MXA-0432` |
| `SM-003` | 15/15 required controls implemented and exposed.                                                                                 | 13/15 controls currently evidenced in related baseline workflows.             | `MXA-0418`, `MXA-0423`, `MXA-0424`, `MXA-0425`                                                                                                                                                             |
| `SM-004` | Average required-control quality score >= 0.75.                                                                                  | Current benchmark baseline: 0.975.                                            | `MXA-0429`, `MXA-0430`                                                                                                                                                                                     |
| `SM-005` | element_silhouette_iou >= 0.80, temporal_flicker_rate <= 0.05, and motion_vector_drift <= 0.08.                                  | Not yet measured for vfx-element-pack baseline (family not implemented).      | `MXA-0419`, `MXA-0429`, `MXA-0430`                                                                                                                                                                         |
| `SM-006` | alpha_edge_halo_rate <= 0.04, premultiplied_alpha_error <= 0.03, and matte_leak_rate <= 0.02.                                    | Not yet measured for vfx-element-pack baseline (family not implemented).      | `MXA-0419`, `MXA-0429`, `MXA-0430`                                                                                                                                                                         |
| `SM-007` | 100% of outputs include package classes required by `preview_image`, `source_frames`, and `metadata_manifest` mappings.          | No dedicated vfx-element-pack output package contract is currently published. | `MXA-0421`, `MXA-0430`                                                                                                                                                                                     |
| `SM-008` | Typed request/response support and user-facing controls available across generation API, SDK, and web UI with zero schema drift. | VFX element pack family not yet exposed on API/SDK/UI surfaces.               | `MXA-0423`, `MXA-0424`, `MXA-0425`                                                                                                                                                                         |

## Failure Criteria

| Criterion | Trigger                                                                                                                                       | Severity | Required Response                                                                                               |
| --------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | -------- | --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| `FC-001`  | Any of baseline, image-conditioned, control-conditioned, or consistency-locked variants is absent or uncertified.                             | high     | Block promotion and complete missing variant tickets before reopening certification.                            |
| `FC-002`  | Any required control ID is missing from workflow metadata or is not exposed consistently in API/SDK/UI.                                       | high     | Fail contract parity checks and block release until missing control contracts and UI exposure are restored.     |
| `FC-003`  | Temporal continuity, silhouette stability, alpha integrity, or compositing-readiness metrics fail thresholds across approved golden datasets. | high     | Reject quality gate, retune workflows/models, and rerun regression benchmark until thresholds pass.             |
| `FC-004`  | Generated outputs are missing required package classes or manifest/checksum artifacts.                                                        | high     | Fail output package validation and block external integrations until packaging contract is restored.            |
| `FC-005`  | Cost estimation or runtime sizing exceeds approved guardrails without explicit override policy.                                               | medium   | Apply hard-fail guardrail behavior and reclassify endpoint sizing before allowing additional runs.              |
| `FC-006`  | Golden dataset or regression suite detects perceptual drift above accepted threshold.                                                         | high     | Mark build as non-releasable, investigate drift root cause, and refresh certification evidence only after pass. |

## Downstream Delivery Map

| Ticket        | Checklist  | Status | Title                                                                                                          |
| ------------- | ---------- | ------ | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| `ISIS2-00614` | `MXA-0416` | DONE   | Design baseline workflow graph for `vfx-element-pack` with deterministic defaults.                             |
| `ISIS2-00615` | `MXA-0417` | DONE   | Design image-conditioned variant workflow for `vfx-element-pack`.                                              |
| `ISIS2-00616` | `MXA-0418` | DONE   | Design control-conditioned variant workflow for `vfx-element-pack` (pose/depth/segmentation where applicable). |
| `ISIS2-00617` | `MXA-0419` | DONE   | Design consistency-locked variant workflow for `vfx-element-pack` with continuity profile support.             |
| `ISIS2-00618` | `MXA-0420` | DONE   | Define model/node dependency manifest for `vfx-element-pack` workflows.                                        |
| `ISIS2-00619` | `MXA-0421` | DONE   | Define output package contract for `vfx-element-pack` including file naming and metadata manifest.             |
| `ISIS2-00620` | `MXA-0422` | DONE   | Add workflow templates and presets for `vfx-element-pack` production tiers (draft/final/hero).                 |
| `ISIS2-00621` | `MXA-0423` | DONE   | Expose `vfx-element-pack` workflows via generation API with typed request contracts.                           |
| `ISIS2-00622` | `MXA-0424` | DONE   | Expose `vfx-element-pack` workflows via SDK with end-to-end examples.                                          |
| `ISIS2-00623` | `MXA-0425` | DONE   | Expose `vfx-element-pack` workflows in web UI with ergonomic form controls and validation.                     |
| `ISIS2-00624` | `MXA-0426` | DONE   | Implement side-by-side comparison tools for `vfx-element-pack` outputs.                                        |
| `ISIS2-00625` | `MXA-0427` | DONE   | Map `vfx-element-pack` workflows to RunPod endpoint classes and sizing policies.                               |
| `ISIS2-00626` | `MXA-0428` | DONE   | Add `vfx-element-pack` cost estimation and budget guardrails.                                                  |
| `ISIS2-00627` | `MXA-0429` | DONE   | Add `vfx-element-pack` quality evaluator and threshold-based acceptance gate.                                  |
| `ISIS2-00628` | `MXA-0430` | DONE   | Add `vfx-element-pack` regression tests and golden datasets.                                                   |
| `ISIS2-00629` | `MXA-0431` | DONE   | Add `vfx-element-pack` external integration recipe for downstream tools/systems.                               |
| `ISIS2-00630` | `MXA-0432` | DONE   | Publish `vfx-element-pack` operator and creator documentation with troubleshooting.                            |

## Traceability

- Checklist item: `MXA-0415`
- Ticket key: `ISIS2-00613`
- Source references:
  - `docs/domains/isis/remediation-v2/ISIS_REMEDIATION_V2_TICKETS.json`
  - `docs/domains/isis/remediation-v2/ISIS_V2_ASSET_TAXONOMY.json`
  - `docs/domains/isis/remediation-v2/ISIS_V2_CONTROL_TAXONOMY.json`
  - `docs/domains/isis/remediation-v2/ISIS_V2_CONSISTENCY_TAXONOMY.json`
  - `docs/domains/isis/remediation-v2/ISIS_V2_OUTPUT_PACKAGE_TAXONOMY.json`
  - `libs/isis/workflows/src/metadata/workflow-taxonomy-registry.json`
  - `docs/domains/isis/remediation-v2/ISIS_V2_BENCHMARK_DASHBOARD.json`
  - `ISIS_TODOS_2.md`
