# GATE-003 Certification: No Simulated Output Path in Production

Date: 2026-02-22  
Checklist Item: `GATE-003`  
Ticket: `ISIS-0253`

## Scope

Certify that simulated output generation paths are fail-closed in production and
cannot be reached when real ComfyUI execution is unavailable.

## Evidence Matrix

| Requirement                                                     | Evidence                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      | Status |
| --------------------------------------------------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------ |
| Production runtime blocks simulated execution fallback          | `apps/isis/generation-api/src/workflows/executor.ts` explicitly throws `WORKFLOW_INCOMPATIBLE` in production when ComfyUI is unavailable, preventing fallback to `simulatedExecution` (`Incompatible workflow runtime: simulated output URL generation is disabled in production when ComfyUI is unavailable.`).              | Pass   |
| Production fail-closed behavior is validated by automated tests | `apps/isis/generation-api/src/workflows/executor.spec.ts` test `fails closed in production when execution would require simulated placeholder output URLs` passed; it sets `NODE_ENV=production` + `DISABLE_COMFYUI_SERVICE=true` and verifies execution fails with `WORKFLOW_INCOMPATIBLE` and the production guard message. | Pass   |
| Unresolved workflow path is fail-closed in production           | `apps/isis/generation-api/src/workflows/executor.spec.ts` test `fails closed with explicit production guard context when unresolved workflow occurs` passed; it verifies production mode emits a fail-closed unresolved-workflow error context rather than permitting unsafe fallback behavior.                               | Pass   |

## Reproduction Commands

```bash
pnpm --filter @isis/generation-api exec vitest run src/workflows/executor.spec.ts -t "(fails closed with explicit production guard context when unresolved workflow occurs|fails closed in production when execution would require simulated placeholder output URLs)"
```
