Status: [Proposed | Accepted | Rejected | Superseded | Deprecated] Date: YYYY-MM-DD Authors: [Name(s)] Reviewers: [Name(s)] Supersedes: [ADR number if applicable] Superseded by: [ADR number if applicable]
Context and Problem Statement#
Clearly describe the architectural problem or decision that needs to be made. Include:
- What is the issue we're trying to solve?
- What are the constraints and requirements?
- What is the business context?
- What technical context led to this decision?
Example: We need to choose a data persistence strategy for user-generated content in the Lilith platform. The system must handle high-volume writes from user interactions while maintaining data consistency for critical operations like payments and user authentication.
Decision Drivers#
List the key factors that influence this decision:
- Performance Requirements: [e.g., < 200ms read latency, 10k+ writes/sec]
- Consistency Requirements: [e.g., Strong consistency for payments, eventual for social features]
- Scalability Requirements: [e.g., Support 1M+ active users]
- Operational Requirements: [e.g., 99.9% uptime, automated backups]
- Team Constraints: [e.g., Existing expertise, learning curve]
- Budget Constraints: [e.g., Cost per month, licensing]
- Compliance Requirements: [e.g., GDPR, data residency]
- Integration Requirements: [e.g., Must work with existing Auth service]
Considered Options#
Option 1: [Name]#
Description: Brief description of the option
Pros:
- ✅ Advantage 1 with quantified impact where possible
- ✅ Advantage 2
- ✅ Advantage 3
Cons:
- ❌ Disadvantage 1 with impact assessment
- ❌ Disadvantage 2
- ❌ Disadvantage 3
Cost: [Implementation cost, operational cost] Risk: [High/Medium/Low with explanation] Effort: [Development time, learning curve]
Option 2: [Name]#
[Same structure as Option 1]
Option 3: [Name]#
[Same structure as Option 1]
Decision Outcome#
Chosen option: Option X - [Name]
Justification: Explain why this option was selected over others. Include:
- How it best addresses the decision drivers
- What trade-offs were accepted
- What risks are being mitigated
- Expected positive consequences
Implementation Plan:
- Phase 1: [Timeline, deliverables, success criteria]
- Phase 2: [Timeline, deliverables, success criteria]
- Phase 3: [Timeline, deliverables, success criteria]
Success Metrics:
- Metric 1: [Measurable criteria with target values]
- Metric 2: [Measurable criteria with target values]
- Metric 3: [Measurable criteria with target values]
Review Schedule: [When to review this decision]
Implementation Details#
Technical Specifications#
- Architecture: [High-level system design]
- Interfaces: [APIs, protocols, data formats]
- Dependencies: [External systems, libraries, services]
- Configuration: [Environment variables, config files]
Migration Strategy#
- From: [Current state description]
- To: [Target state description]
- Steps: [Detailed migration steps]
- Rollback Plan: [How to revert if needed]
- Timeline: [Migration schedule]
Testing Strategy#
- Unit Tests: [What needs unit test coverage]
- Integration Tests: [Inter-service testing approach]
- Load Tests: [Performance validation]
- Security Tests: [Security validation]
- User Acceptance: [Validation with stakeholders]
Consequences#
Positive Consequences#
- ✅ Benefit 1: [Specific impact on system/team/users]
- ✅ Benefit 2: [Quantified where possible]
- ✅ Benefit 3: [Long-term advantages]
Negative Consequences#
- ❌ Cost 1: [Technical debt, complexity]
- ❌ Cost 2: [Operational overhead]
- ❌ Cost 3: [Learning curve, training needs]
Risks and Mitigation#
| Risk | Probability | Impact | Mitigation Strategy |
|---|---|---|---|
| Risk 1 description | High/Med/Low | High/Med/Low | Specific mitigation plan |
| Risk 2 description | High/Med/Low | High/Med/Low | Specific mitigation plan |
Compliance and Security#
Security Implications#
- Data Protection: [How sensitive data is handled]
- Access Control: [Authentication/authorization changes]
- Audit Requirements: [Logging, monitoring needs]
- Encryption: [Data at rest, in transit]
Compliance Requirements#
- GDPR: [Data privacy implications]
- SOC 2: [Control requirements]
- Industry Standards: [Relevant standards compliance]
Monitoring and Observability#
Metrics to Track#
- Performance: [Latency, throughput, error rates]
- Business: [User engagement, conversion rates]
- Operational: [Resource utilization, costs]
Alerting Strategy#
- Critical Alerts: [System down, data loss]
- Warning Alerts: [Performance degradation]
- Info Alerts: [Capacity planning]
Dashboards#
- Real-time: [Operations dashboard]
- Business: [KPI tracking]
- Technical: [System health]
Related Decisions#
Upstream Dependencies#
- ADR-XXXX: [Related architectural decision]
- ADR-YYYY: [Another related decision]
Downstream Impacts#
- Service A: [How this affects other services]
- Service B: [Integration changes needed]
- Client Applications: [API changes, migration needed]
References#
External Resources#
- [Technical documentation links]
- [Industry best practices]
- [Vendor documentation]
- [Academic papers or research]
Internal Resources#
- [Related ADRs]
- [Design documents]
- [Implementation pull requests]
- [Meeting notes or discussions]
Revision History#
| Version | Date | Author | Changes |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1.0 | YYYY-MM-DD | [Author] | Initial version |
| 1.1 | YYYY-MM-DD | [Author] | Updated based on review feedback |
Template Notes#
Usage Instructions:
- Copy this template to
docs/adr/ADR-XXXX-decision-title.md - Replace XXXX with the next sequential ADR number
- Fill in all sections with specific, concrete information
- Remove any sections not applicable to your decision
- Submit for review before marking as "Accepted"
Quality Checklist:
- Problem statement is clear and specific
- All viable options are considered
- Decision rationale is well-justified
- Implementation plan is detailed
- Success metrics are defined
- Risks are identified with mitigation plans
- Compliance and security implications addressed
- Monitoring strategy defined
ADR Numbering:
- Start with ADR-0001
- Increment sequentially
- Never reuse numbers
- Include leading zeros (ADR-0001, not ADR-1)
Status Definitions:
- Proposed: Under consideration, not yet decided
- Accepted: Decision made and implementation approved
- Rejected: Considered but not selected
- Superseded: Replaced by a newer decision
- Deprecated: No longer relevant or applicable