Date: 2025-09-14 Status: Accepted Authors: @team Reviewers: @architecture-team Deciders: @tech-lead
Context#
The Lilith project requires a scalable architecture to support multiple AI-powered services including chat, content delivery, speech synthesis, and user management. The system needs to:
- Support independent deployment and scaling of different components
- Enable different teams to work on different services without blocking each other
- Provide flexibility to choose different technologies for different use cases
- Maintain high availability and fault isolation
- Support rapid iteration and feature development
Key constraints:
- Team has strong Node.js expertise
- Need sub-second response times for chat interactions
- Must support both real-time (WebSocket/SSE) and batch processing
- Integration with multiple external AI providers required
- Kubernetes deployment target
Decision#
We will implement a microservices architecture using Fastify as the web framework for individual services, with a Backend-for-Frontend (BFF) pattern for client aggregation.
Key architectural components:
- Individual services for auth, content, conversation, ai, media, notification, moderation
- BFF service to aggregate and shape responses for different client types
- Service mesh (Istio) for inter-service communication and security
- Event-driven communication for async operations
- Shared libraries for common functionality (logging, validation, etc.)
Rationale#
Why microservices:
- Enables independent scaling (AI service can scale differently than user management)
- Allows technology diversity (Python for ML components, Node.js for API services)
- Supports team autonomy and parallel development
- Provides fault isolation (failure in one service doesn't bring down others)
- Matches our deployment target (Kubernetes)
Why Fastify:
- Excellent performance (faster than Express.js)
- Built-in schema validation and serialization
- Strong TypeScript support
- Plugin ecosystem for common requirements
- Lightweight and fast startup times
- Good observability hooks
Why BFF pattern:
- Different clients (web, mobile, API) have different data needs
- Reduces client-server round trips through aggregation
- Enables client-specific optimizations (response shaping, caching)
- Centralizes cross-cutting concerns (auth, rate limiting, error normalization)
Alternatives Considered#
Option 1: Monolithic Architecture#
- Description: Single large application with all functionality
- Pros: Simpler deployment, no distributed system complexity, easier debugging
- Cons: Difficult to scale individual components, technology lock-in, team bottlenecks
- Decision: Rejected due to scaling and team autonomy requirements
Option 2: Express.js Framework#
- Description: Use Express.js instead of Fastify for services
- Pros: More mature ecosystem, team familiarity, extensive middleware
- Cons: Lower performance, more boilerplate required, weaker schema validation
- Decision: Rejected due to performance requirements and built-in validation needs
Option 3: GraphQL Federation#
- Description: Use GraphQL with federated schema across services
- Pros: Strong typing, efficient data fetching, good tooling
- Cons: Additional complexity, learning curve, caching challenges
- Decision: Rejected due to team expertise and caching requirements
Implementation#
Technical Changes Required#
- Create service template with Fastify setup
- Implement BFF service with aggregation logic
- Set up service mesh with Istio
- Create shared libraries for common functionality
- Implement service discovery and health checks
Service Boundaries#
- Auth: User management, JWT tokens, RBAC
- Conversation: Chat threads, message storage, WebSocket management
- AI: LLM orchestration, prompt management, provider routing
- Content: Course management, media metadata, versioning
- Media: File storage, transcoding, signed URLs
- Notification: Push notifications, email, templates
- Moderation: Safety filters, content policies
- BFF: Request aggregation, client-specific response shaping
Testing Strategy#
- Unit tests for individual service logic
- Integration tests for service-to-service communication
- Contract tests for API boundaries
- End-to-end tests for complete user workflows
- Performance tests for latency and throughput requirements
Impact Assessment#
Services Affected#
- All services: New microservices architecture affects entire system
- Deployment: Kubernetes-native deployment with Helm charts
- Monitoring: Distributed tracing and service mesh observability
Performance Impact#
- Positive: Better resource utilization, independent scaling
- Negative: Network latency between services (mitigated by service mesh)
- Target: Maintain <200ms p50 latency for API endpoints
Security Implications#
- Service-to-service authentication via mTLS
- API gateway for external traffic
- Secrets management per service
- RBAC enforcement at service boundaries
Operational Impact#
- More complex deployment and monitoring
- Distributed logging and tracing required
- Service discovery and health checking
- Circuit breakers and retry policies
Metrics & Success Criteria#
Performance metrics:
- API response times: p50 < 200ms, p95 < 500ms
- Service startup time: < 5 seconds
- Resource efficiency: CPU and memory usage per service
Quality metrics:
- Service availability: 99.9% uptime
- Error rates: < 0.1% for critical paths
- Deployment frequency: Multiple deployments per day per service
Business metrics:
- Developer velocity: Faster feature delivery
- Team autonomy: Reduced cross-team dependencies
Timeline#
- Decision deadline: 2025-09-01 ✓
- Implementation start: 2025-09-01 ✓
- Core services complete: 2025-09-14 ✓
- Production deployment: 2025-10-01
- Review/evaluation: 2025-12-01
Dependencies#
- Kubernetes cluster setup and Istio service mesh
- CI/CD pipeline for independent service deployments
- Monitoring and observability stack (Prometheus, Grafana, Jaeger)
- Shared component library development
Risks & Mitigation#
| Risk | Impact | Likelihood | Mitigation Strategy |
|---|---|---|---|
| Distributed system complexity | High | Medium | Comprehensive testing, circuit breakers, fallbacks |
| Network latency between services | Medium | High | Service mesh optimization, smart caching |
| Debugging across services | High | Medium | Distributed tracing, correlation IDs |
| Service dependency management | Medium | Medium | Health checks, graceful degradation |
Communication Plan#
- Architecture overview presentation to all engineers
- Service boundary documentation in team wiki
- Migration plan communicated to stakeholders
- Regular architecture review meetings established
References#
- Microservices.io patterns
- Fastify documentation
- Backend-for-Frontend pattern
- Internal service template repository
- Kubernetes deployment guides
Review Notes#
Review 1 (2025-09-01)#
- Reviewer: @senior-architect
- Comments: Approved architecture approach, suggested adding circuit breakers
- Action items: Document circuit breaker patterns ✓
Review 2 (2025-09-01)#
- Reviewer: @platform-team-lead
- Comments: Deployment strategy looks good, need service mesh training
- Action items: Schedule Istio training sessions ✓
Amendment History#
| Date | Author | Change | Reason |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2025-09-14 | @team | Added BFF pattern details | Based on implementation experience |