Eve library

Grand Campaign - Meta-Game Research

Research

Revision 1

On this page

Research Date: December 2024 Purpose: Foundation research for Grand Strategy Campaign integrating all Veilborn game modes


1. Twilight Imperium Phase Structure#

Round Structure#

Four Phases Per Round:

  1. Strategy Phase
  2. Action Phase
  3. Status Phase
  4. Agenda Phase (after Mecatol Rex activated)

Strategy Phase#

Core Mechanic:

  • Players choose strategy cards in turn order
  • Cards determine initiative (turn order)
  • Trade goods on unchosen cards accumulate
  • 3-4 player games: Each player chooses 2 cards

Strategic Cards Provide:

  • Primary ability for choosing player
  • Secondary ability available to all other players
  • Action types: Strategic, Component, Tactical

Action Phase#

Action Types:

  • Strategic Actions: Resolve strategy card primary ability
  • Component Actions: Use printed action on game component
  • Tactical Actions: Spend command token for movement/combat

Key Rule: Cannot pass until strategic action performed.

Status Phase#

Sequence:

  1. Score objectives
  2. Reveal new objective
  3. Draw action cards
  4. Remove command tokens from board
  5. Gain 2 command tokens, redistribute
  6. Ready exhausted cards
  7. Repair units
  8. Return strategy cards

Agenda Phase#

Triggers: After Mecatol Rex custodians removed.

Function:

  • Political voting on game-affecting laws
  • Two agendas revealed per phase
  • Vote using influence

Victory Condition#

10 Victory Points wins immediately

  • Scored through objectives
  • Public and secret objectives

Application to Grand Campaign#

Recommended Phase Structure:

  1. Strategy Phase: Faction abilities, resource allocation
  2. Conflict Phase: Individual mode resolution
  3. Diplomacy Phase: Weave connections, treaties
  4. Status Phase: Scoring, cleanup, persistence

2. Gloomhaven Legacy Campaign Mechanics#

Progression Systems#

Character Development:

  • XP accumulation → Level up
  • Replace basic cards with powerful ones
  • Perks refine modifier deck (20 per class)
  • Retirement via personal goals

Retirement Innovation:

  • Personal goal completion → Retirement
  • Unlocks new character classes
  • Forces experiencing multiple characters
  • Prevents gameplay stagnation

City Prosperity#

What It Affects:

  • Shop inventory availability
  • Enhancement options
  • Starting character levels

How It Changes:

  • Scenario successes
  • Event outcomes
  • Player decisions

Unlockable Content#

Hidden Content Types:

  • Sealed envelope character classes
  • New scenarios
  • Town and travel events
  • Lore revelations
  • Game mechanics

Design Principle: Pleasure of discovery drives engagement.

Party Persistence#

Tracked Elements:

  • Party achievements
  • Reputation
  • Current location
  • Character goals progress

Flexibility:

  • Party composition changes over time
  • Characters retire, new ones created
  • Multi-session continuity

Application to Grand Campaign#

Recommended Progression:

  • Faction prosperity tracks
  • Character retirement → New commanders
  • Sealed content based on prophecy fulfillment
  • Weave-driven unlocks

3. Pandemic Legacy Permanent Changes#

Sticker System#

Types of Stickers:

  • City status stickers (panic levels)
  • Character ability stickers
  • Rule modification stickers
  • Board alteration stickers

Key Property: Once placed, cannot be removed.

World State Changes#

Panic System:

  • Level 1: Minimal effect
  • Level 2-3: Rioting (restrictions)
  • Level 4-5: Dire straits (severe penalties)

Fading Cities:

  • Permanent transformation of cities
  • Spreads through outbreaks
  • Changes gameplay fundamentally

Rule Evolution#

Blank Spaces in Rulebook:

  • Designed for rule additions
  • Sticker-based rule changes
  • Sections that unlock later

Sealed Content Design#

Dossier System:

  • Numbered packages
  • Opened when conditions met
  • Contains stickers, rules, components
  • Resolve sequentially

Application to Grand Campaign#

Recommended Permanent Changes:

  • Territory corruption levels
  • Ley line modifications
  • Prophecy fulfillment stickers
  • Weave state alterations
  • Character scars/abilities

4. Risk Legacy World Modification#

First Legacy Game (2011)#

Innovation: Permanent changes to game components.

Types of Modifications:

  • Writing on board
  • Stickers on cards/board
  • Destroying (tearing up) cards
  • Rule additions

Winner Bonuses#

Major Bonus Options (first 15 games):

  • Found major city (exclusive start position)
  • Delete permanent modifier from board
  • Destroy country card
  • Change continent troop bonus
  • Name continent (personal troop bonus)

Sealed Content System#

Trigger-Based Opening:

  • Pre-set conditions for each package
  • Contains new rules, components
  • Surprise and anticipation

Evolving Rulebook#

Design:

  • Blank spaces for additions
  • Rule sections unlock later
  • Physical rulebook changes

Not Disposable#

Key Insight: Game is customized, not used up.

  • Can continue past 15-game campaign
  • Unique copy of Risk
  • Replayability in final state

Application to Grand Campaign#

Recommended Permanence:

  • Territory naming rights
  • Founder bonuses
  • Destroyed resources/cards
  • Named NPCs and locations
  • Victory monuments

5. Multi-Session Persistence Patterns#

Common Persistence Methods#

Physical Mechanisms:

  • Character sheets
  • Campaign logs
  • Stickers/markers
  • Sealed envelopes
  • Token storage

Digital Mechanisms:

  • Save game state
  • Cloud synchronization
  • Campaign database
  • Player profiles

State Elements to Persist#

Character State:

  • Level/XP
  • Equipment/inventory
  • Abilities/skills
  • Relationships

World State:

  • Territory control
  • Resource availability
  • Event history
  • NPC states

Campaign State:

  • Completed objectives
  • Unlocked content
  • Timeline position
  • Score/standing

Session Management#

Between Sessions:

  • Clear save state mechanism
  • Photo documentation (physical)
  • State validation on resume
  • Conflict resolution for discrepancies

Application to Grand Campaign#

Recommended Persistence:

  • Full game state serialization
  • Cloud save for digital play
  • Physical campaign journal option
  • QR code state encoding

6. Player Dropout Handling#

The Core Problem#

Long Campaigns Face:

  • Life events causing absences
  • Schedule conflicts
  • Player fatigue/disinterest
  • Group composition changes

Design Solutions#

Narrative Excuses:

  • "Chaos Curse" (character teleports away)
  • Mission assignments elsewhere
  • Injury/recovery
  • Captured/rescue mission later

Mechanical Solutions:

  • Bot/AI replacement
  • Proxy player option
  • Faction automation rules
  • "War Will" flexible participation

Prevention Strategies#

Design Considerations:

  • Don't make absent player's character plot-critical
  • Modular story threads
  • Catch-up mechanisms
  • Flexible victory conditions

Replacement Integration#

New Player Onboarding:

  • Quick start guide
  • Catch-up resources
  • Starting position balance
  • Narrative integration point

Application to Grand Campaign#

Recommended Handling:

  • AI takes over absent faction
  • Proxy voting for decisions
  • Reduced agency (defensive only)
  • Narrative "away on mission"
  • New player friendly entry points

7. Emergent Narrative (from CK3 Research - Mode 1)#

See: veil-war-game-design-research.md for detailed CK3 analysis

Key Systems#

Character-Driven Stories:

  • Personality traits affect AI decisions
  • Relationships develop organically
  • Secrets and schemes create reveals
  • Dynasties persist across generations

Stress System:

  • Actions against personality cause stress
  • Stress leads to mental breaks
  • Creates meaningful roleplay decisions

Dynasty Legacies:

  • Long-term upgrades across generations
  • Multi-session investment
  • Creates attachment to family lines

Cultural/Religious Innovation:

  • Cultures evolve over time
  • Players can reform systems
  • Unique alternate histories

Application to Grand Campaign#

Recommended Systems:

  • Commander personality traits
  • Faction dynasty progression
  • Weave-driven event chains
  • Cultural evolution of factions
  • Prophecy-based narrative triggers

8. Design Recommendations for Grand Campaign#

Phase Structure#

Phase 1: Genesis (Setup)

  • Faction drafting
  • Starting position selection
  • Prophecy distribution
  • Weave relationship seeding
  • Difficulty settings

Phase 2: Expansion (Early Game)

  • Territory claiming (Veil War lite)
  • Early resource accumulation
  • First contact diplomacy
  • Exploration mechanics

Phase 3: Conflict (Mid Game)

  • War declaration requirements
  • Battle resolution (Resonance Wars)
  • Alliance formation
  • Temporal manipulation (Echoes of Fate)
  • Conspiracy activation (Weave Conspiracy)

Phase 4: Revelation (Late Game)

  • Hidden agenda reveals
  • Major prophecy resolutions
  • Weave tension peaks
  • Final conflict preparation

Phase 5: Ascension (Endgame)

  • Final battle for dominance
  • Multiple victory paths
  • Epilogue narration
  • Campaign scoring

Mode Integration#

How Modes Combine: | Situation | Mode Used | |-----------|-----------| | Territorial conflict | Veil War | | Tactical battles | Resonance Wars | | Prophecy/temporal crisis | Echoes of Fate | | Mystical site control | Eternal Game | | Alliance management | Weave Conspiracy |

Persistence Architecture#

Per-Session Saves:

  • Full game state JSON
  • Weave connection graph
  • Territory ownership
  • Resource pools
  • Character states
  • Prophecy progress

Permanent Changes:

  • Named territories
  • Fulfilled prophecies
  • Character deaths
  • Faction achievements
  • World modifications

Player Dropout Handling#

Absent Player Rules:

  1. Faction enters "Defensive Mode"
  2. AI makes conservative decisions
  3. No offensive actions
  4. Can be targeted but with penalties
  5. Catch-up bonus on return

Replacement Player Rules:

  1. Can join mid-campaign
  2. Take over AI-controlled faction
  3. Starting bonus based on catch-up calculation
  4. Full integration tutorial

Victory Conditions#

Multiple Paths:

  1. Dominance: Control majority of territories
  2. Prophecy: Fulfill X major prophecies
  3. Weave: Achieve Weave dominance state
  4. Alliance: Lead winning coalition
  5. Ascension: Complete faction-specific goal

References#

  • Twilight Imperium 4th Edition Rules Reference
  • Gloomhaven Campaign Tracker - Cephalofair Games
  • Pandemic Legacy: Season 1 Rulebook - Z-Man Games
  • Risk Legacy - Hasbro/Avalon Hill
  • Crusader Kings 3 Wiki - Paradox Interactive
  • "Best Multi-Session Board Games" - Game Rant
  • TV Tropes - Drop-In-Drop-Out Multiplayer
  • BGG Geeklist - Saving Board Game Sessions