Research Date: December 2024 Purpose: Foundation research for Weave Conspiracy hidden role social deduction mode
1. The Resistance / Avalon Mechanics#
Core Game Structure#
Setup:
- 5-10 players divided into Good (Servants of Arthur) and Evil (Minions of Mordred)
- Evil players know each other's identities
- Good players have majority but don't know who anyone is
Mission Mechanic:
- Leader proposes team for mission
- All players vote to approve/reject team
- Approved team goes on mission
- Team members secretly play Pass/Fail cards
- Single Fail card fails the mission (usually)
Victory Conditions:
- Good wins: Complete 3 of 5 missions successfully
- Evil wins: Fail 3 missions OR identify Merlin at end
Special Roles (Avalon)#
Merlin:
- Knows who Evil players are
- Must communicate in riddles/hints
- If Good wins, Evil can guess Merlin for last-chance victory
Percival:
- Knows who Merlin is
- Can protect Merlin by drawing attention
Morgana:
- Appears as Merlin to Percival
- Creates confusion about true Merlin identity
Oberon:
- Evil but doesn't know other Evil players
- Other Evil don't know Oberon
- Disrupts Evil coordination
Design Lessons#
- Asymmetric Information: Evil knows, Good deduces
- Hidden Identities: Core tension from unknown allegiances
- Public Actions: Voting creates trackable patterns
- Private Sabotage: Mission cards allow secret betrayal
- End-Game Twist: Merlin reveal adds final dramatic moment
2. Battlestar Galactica Hidden Traitor System#
Sleeper Agent Mechanic#
Revolutionary Innovation: Players may not know they're traitors at start.
How It Works:
- Initial loyalty cards dealt at game start
- After Distance 4 jump: Second loyalty cards dealt
- Any Cylon card = player is now Cylon
- Creates uncertainty even for players about own loyalty
Implications:
- Early game: Everyone might be helping humans
- Mid-game: Loyalty shift creates dramatic reveals
- Late game: Known Cylons work openly against humans
Skill Check Sabotage#
Mechanism:
- Crisis cards require skill checks
- All players can contribute cards secretly
- Cards shuffled before reveal
- Negative cards cause check failure
Strategic Depth:
- Cylons can quietly sabotage without detection
- Good players analyze failed checks for patterns
- Accusation and discussion during/after checks
- Resource management (choosing which checks to help)
Cylon Revelation#
When to Reveal:
- Revealed Cylons lose subtlety but gain new powers
- Move to Cylon locations with specific actions
- Timing of reveal is strategic decision
- Early reveal = more overt actions, less sabotage
Win Conditions#
Cylons Win If:
- Galactica destroyed (6+ damage locations)
- Any resource drops to zero
- Centurions reach end of boarding track
Humans Win If:
- Galactica reaches Kobol with resources intact
3. Blood on the Clocktower Role Complexity#
Design Philosophy#
Every Player Has Unique Role:
- No "vanilla" villagers
- Each role has powers/requirements
- Complexity as intentional design choice
- Learning curve accepted for depth
Qualitative Differentiation:
- Moved away from "+1, -1" power design
- Characters wildly, qualitatively different
- Abilities interact in complex ways
- Scripts (role sets) curate combinations
Information Economy#
Core Insight: Good social deduction isn't about hiding information but strategically fragmenting it.
How It Works:
- Each role provides partial information
- No single player has complete picture
- Collaboration required to piece together truth
- "Lens of mystery" - everyone sees differently
Dead Players Stay Engaged#
Innovation: Death doesn't end participation.
Mechanics:
- Dead players retain single vote
- Some roles activate on death
- Ghost information still valuable
- Maintains engagement throughout game
Script System#
Curated Role Sets:
- "Trouble Brewing" - Introductory
- "Sects & Violets" - Intermediate
- "Bad Moon Rising" - Advanced
Custom Scripts:
- Storytellers can mix and match
- CCG-like deck construction for roles
- Infinite replayability
Storyteller Role#
Active Game Master:
- Not just facilitating - making judgment calls
- Can adjust difficulty mid-game
- Creates dramatic moments
- Lies to evil players (some roles)
4. Secret Hitler Fascist/Liberal Balance#
Team Composition Balance#
| Players | Liberals | Fascists | Including Hitler |
|---|---|---|---|
| 5-6 | 3-4 | 2 | Yes |
| 7-8 | 4-5 | 3 | Yes |
| 9-10 | 5-6 | 4 | Yes |
Key Balance:
- Liberals always majority
- Fascists know each other
- Hitler special: In 5-6p knows fascists; in 7+p doesn't
Policy Deck Design#
Composition: 11 Fascist, 6 Liberal (nearly 2:1 ratio)
Design Intent:
- Forces some fascist actions from liberals
- Provides cover for fascist plays
- Creates plausible deniability
- Prevents trivial liberal victories
Victory Conditions#
Liberals Win:
- Enact 5 Liberal policies, OR
- Assassinate Hitler
Fascists Win:
- Enact 6 Fascist policies, OR
- Elect Hitler as Chancellor after 3+ Fascist policies
Hitler Mechanic as Strategy Core#
Insight from Playtesting:
- Hitler election win condition is crucial
- Makes Hitler trustworthiness key strategy
- Disrupts liberal trust networks
- Risk creates tension in mid-late game
7-Player Sweet Spot#
Why 7 is Most Balanced:
- 4 Liberals vs 3 Fascists
- Hitler doesn't know fascists
- Enough players for uncertainty
- Not so many that analysis paralysis
5. Digital Social Deduction (Among Us, Town of Salem)#
Among Us Innovation#
Real-Time Action + Social Deduction:
- Tasks provide alibis
- Physical location matters
- Kill animations require opportunity
- Emergency meetings for discussion
Rules-Light Design:
- Minimal mechanical complexity
- Easy to learn
- Social interaction drives gameplay
- Visual/physical evidence supplements discussion
Detection Methods:
- Witnessed kills
- Task completion tracking (visual tasks)
- Location/movement analysis
- Behavioral tells
Town of Salem Role System#
48 Unique Roles:
- Good, Evil, and Neutral factions
- Each with distinct abilities
- Night actions vs Day voting
- Role reveals on death
Information Architecture:
- Investigators gather specific info
- Doctors/bodyguards protect
- Serial killers/mafia kill
- Jesters have anti-goals
Cross-Pollination:
- Among Us mods import Town of Salem roles
- Doctor, Jester, Sheriff mechanics adapted
- Proves modular role design works
Key Differences#
| Aspect | Among Us | Town of Salem |
|---|---|---|
| Complexity | Low | High |
| Real-time | Yes | No |
| Role count | 2-4 | 48+ |
| Learning curve | Minutes | Hours |
| Evidence type | Visual/physical | Mechanical/logical |
6. Nemesis Hidden Objectives#
Semi-Cooperative Design#
Core Tension:
- Players need to cooperate to survive
- Each player has hidden personal objective
- Objectives may conflict with group survival
- Multiple winners possible
Objective System#
Two Decks:
- Corporate Objectives
- Personal Objectives
Selection Mechanic:
- Each player gets 1 from each deck
- Must choose one when first alien appears
- Discard the other
- Hidden until game end
Objective Types#
Examples:
- Survive and reach specific destination
- Be the only survivor
- Ensure specific character dies
- Collect certain items
- Ship reaches specific coordinate
Design Insight:
- Even "traitors" need group help initially
- Late-game betrayals most effective
- Objectives vary in difficulty
- Some objectives compatible, some contradictory
Cooperative Mode Alternative#
Full Co-op Option:
- Special objective deck
- All objectives must complete
- At least one character survives
- Removes betrayal tension
7. Anti-Kingmaking in Social Deduction#
Kingmaking Definition#
Two Simultaneous Conditions:
- Player feels they've lost the game
- That player decides who wins
Why It Feels Bad:
- Violates implicit fair play contract
- "Best player" expectation broken
- Creates meta-game grudges
- Reduces strategic satisfaction
Mitigation Strategies#
Score Opacity:
- Hide scores until end
- Blur winning line
- Create uncertainty about who's winning
Close Positioning:
- Keep all players in contention
- Comeback mechanisms
- Catch-up mechanics
Interaction Strength:
- Many small interactions > few large ones
- Reduce individual impact
- Distribute decision points
Rule Variations:
- Points don't automatically transfer
- Active gain required, not passive loss
- Reduce zero-sum interactions
Embracing Kingmaking#
Alternative Perspective (Cole Wehrle):
- Kingmaking creates stories
- Manipulation, alliances, betrayal narratives
- Social creatures naturally form alliances
- Part of emergent gameplay
When It Works:
- Highly interactive games
- Short game length
- Social/party contexts
- When narrative > competition
Application to Weave Conspiracy#
Mitigation Approaches:
- Hidden victory points
- Multiple paths to victory
- Late-game reveals change calculations
- Personal objectives reduce pure kingmaking
8. Design Recommendations for Weave Conspiracy#
Hidden Agenda System#
Public Allegiance:
- Visible faction assignment (Path affiliation)
- Known abilities and resources
- Creates baseline trust/suspicion
Hidden Agenda Types: | Agenda | Description | Win Condition | |--------|-------------|---------------| | True Believer | Loyal to faction | Faction wins | | Ambitious Usurper | Self-serving | Highest-ranked survivor | | Void Touched | Secretly corrupted | Allied casualties (hidden) | | Double Agent | Serving hidden faction | Complete secret missions | | Prophet | Prophecy-focused | Fulfill specific prophecy | | Pacifist | Peace-seeker | Prevent major battles | | Martyr | Sacrifice-seeker | Die heroically | | Collector | Resource-focused | Acquire specific items |
Information Fragmentation (Blood on Clocktower Style)#
Veil Sight Abilities:
- Different players see different information
- "Weave Reading" reveals partial truths
- Multiple readings needed for full picture
- Deception possible even in revelations
Accusation System#
Formal Accusations:
- Cost Veil Points to accuse
- Evidence requirements
- Defense opportunity
- Community vote on guilt
Consequences:
- Guilty: Lose influence, reveal agenda
- Innocent: Accuser loses credibility
- Creates risk in accusations
Sleeper Agent Adaptation#
Void Corruption Progression:
- Characters can become corrupted over time
- Hidden corruption track
- Triggers at certain thresholds
- "You were good, now you're not"
Weave Connection Integration#
Relationship-Based Deduction:
- Weave connections reveal information
- Strong bonds create trust OR vulnerability
- Betrayals create narrative drama
- Connections persist across game modes
Anti-Kingmaking Measures#
Multiple Victory Conditions:
- Faction victory
- Personal agenda completion
- Prophecy fulfillment
- Survival points
Hidden Scoring:
- True scores revealed at end
- Mid-game uncertainty maintained
- Reduces strategic kingmaking
Catch-Up Mechanics:
- Suspicion reduction through good deeds
- Redemption arcs possible
- Late-game revelations can flip outcomes
References#
- The Resistance: Avalon - Don Eskridge (Indie Boards & Cards)
- Battlestar Galactica: The Board Game - Fantasy Flight Games
- Blood on the Clocktower - Steven Medway (The Pandemonium Institute)
- Secret Hitler - Goat, Wolf, & Cabbage LLC
- Among Us - Innersloth
- Town of Salem - BlankMediaGames
- Nemesis - Adam Kwapinski (Awaken Realms)
- "Mitigating Kingmaking in Multiplayer Board Games" - DiVA Portal
- "King Me: A Defense of King-Making" - Cole Wehrle (GDC)
- "Social Deduction Game Design Fundamentals" - BKGameDesign