Eve library

Weave Conspiracy - Social Deduction Research

Research

Revision 1

On this page

Research Date: December 2024 Purpose: Foundation research for Weave Conspiracy hidden role social deduction mode


1. The Resistance / Avalon Mechanics#

Core Game Structure#

Setup:

  • 5-10 players divided into Good (Servants of Arthur) and Evil (Minions of Mordred)
  • Evil players know each other's identities
  • Good players have majority but don't know who anyone is

Mission Mechanic:

  • Leader proposes team for mission
  • All players vote to approve/reject team
  • Approved team goes on mission
  • Team members secretly play Pass/Fail cards
  • Single Fail card fails the mission (usually)

Victory Conditions:

  • Good wins: Complete 3 of 5 missions successfully
  • Evil wins: Fail 3 missions OR identify Merlin at end

Special Roles (Avalon)#

Merlin:

  • Knows who Evil players are
  • Must communicate in riddles/hints
  • If Good wins, Evil can guess Merlin for last-chance victory

Percival:

  • Knows who Merlin is
  • Can protect Merlin by drawing attention

Morgana:

  • Appears as Merlin to Percival
  • Creates confusion about true Merlin identity

Oberon:

  • Evil but doesn't know other Evil players
  • Other Evil don't know Oberon
  • Disrupts Evil coordination

Design Lessons#

  1. Asymmetric Information: Evil knows, Good deduces
  2. Hidden Identities: Core tension from unknown allegiances
  3. Public Actions: Voting creates trackable patterns
  4. Private Sabotage: Mission cards allow secret betrayal
  5. End-Game Twist: Merlin reveal adds final dramatic moment

2. Battlestar Galactica Hidden Traitor System#

Sleeper Agent Mechanic#

Revolutionary Innovation: Players may not know they're traitors at start.

How It Works:

  • Initial loyalty cards dealt at game start
  • After Distance 4 jump: Second loyalty cards dealt
  • Any Cylon card = player is now Cylon
  • Creates uncertainty even for players about own loyalty

Implications:

  • Early game: Everyone might be helping humans
  • Mid-game: Loyalty shift creates dramatic reveals
  • Late game: Known Cylons work openly against humans

Skill Check Sabotage#

Mechanism:

  • Crisis cards require skill checks
  • All players can contribute cards secretly
  • Cards shuffled before reveal
  • Negative cards cause check failure

Strategic Depth:

  • Cylons can quietly sabotage without detection
  • Good players analyze failed checks for patterns
  • Accusation and discussion during/after checks
  • Resource management (choosing which checks to help)

Cylon Revelation#

When to Reveal:

  • Revealed Cylons lose subtlety but gain new powers
  • Move to Cylon locations with specific actions
  • Timing of reveal is strategic decision
  • Early reveal = more overt actions, less sabotage

Win Conditions#

Cylons Win If:

  • Galactica destroyed (6+ damage locations)
  • Any resource drops to zero
  • Centurions reach end of boarding track

Humans Win If:

  • Galactica reaches Kobol with resources intact

3. Blood on the Clocktower Role Complexity#

Design Philosophy#

Every Player Has Unique Role:

  • No "vanilla" villagers
  • Each role has powers/requirements
  • Complexity as intentional design choice
  • Learning curve accepted for depth

Qualitative Differentiation:

  • Moved away from "+1, -1" power design
  • Characters wildly, qualitatively different
  • Abilities interact in complex ways
  • Scripts (role sets) curate combinations

Information Economy#

Core Insight: Good social deduction isn't about hiding information but strategically fragmenting it.

How It Works:

  • Each role provides partial information
  • No single player has complete picture
  • Collaboration required to piece together truth
  • "Lens of mystery" - everyone sees differently

Dead Players Stay Engaged#

Innovation: Death doesn't end participation.

Mechanics:

  • Dead players retain single vote
  • Some roles activate on death
  • Ghost information still valuable
  • Maintains engagement throughout game

Script System#

Curated Role Sets:

  • "Trouble Brewing" - Introductory
  • "Sects & Violets" - Intermediate
  • "Bad Moon Rising" - Advanced

Custom Scripts:

  • Storytellers can mix and match
  • CCG-like deck construction for roles
  • Infinite replayability

Storyteller Role#

Active Game Master:

  • Not just facilitating - making judgment calls
  • Can adjust difficulty mid-game
  • Creates dramatic moments
  • Lies to evil players (some roles)

4. Secret Hitler Fascist/Liberal Balance#

Team Composition Balance#

Players Liberals Fascists Including Hitler
5-6 3-4 2 Yes
7-8 4-5 3 Yes
9-10 5-6 4 Yes

Key Balance:

  • Liberals always majority
  • Fascists know each other
  • Hitler special: In 5-6p knows fascists; in 7+p doesn't

Policy Deck Design#

Composition: 11 Fascist, 6 Liberal (nearly 2:1 ratio)

Design Intent:

  • Forces some fascist actions from liberals
  • Provides cover for fascist plays
  • Creates plausible deniability
  • Prevents trivial liberal victories

Victory Conditions#

Liberals Win:

  • Enact 5 Liberal policies, OR
  • Assassinate Hitler

Fascists Win:

  • Enact 6 Fascist policies, OR
  • Elect Hitler as Chancellor after 3+ Fascist policies

Hitler Mechanic as Strategy Core#

Insight from Playtesting:

  • Hitler election win condition is crucial
  • Makes Hitler trustworthiness key strategy
  • Disrupts liberal trust networks
  • Risk creates tension in mid-late game

7-Player Sweet Spot#

Why 7 is Most Balanced:

  • 4 Liberals vs 3 Fascists
  • Hitler doesn't know fascists
  • Enough players for uncertainty
  • Not so many that analysis paralysis

5. Digital Social Deduction (Among Us, Town of Salem)#

Among Us Innovation#

Real-Time Action + Social Deduction:

  • Tasks provide alibis
  • Physical location matters
  • Kill animations require opportunity
  • Emergency meetings for discussion

Rules-Light Design:

  • Minimal mechanical complexity
  • Easy to learn
  • Social interaction drives gameplay
  • Visual/physical evidence supplements discussion

Detection Methods:

  • Witnessed kills
  • Task completion tracking (visual tasks)
  • Location/movement analysis
  • Behavioral tells

Town of Salem Role System#

48 Unique Roles:

  • Good, Evil, and Neutral factions
  • Each with distinct abilities
  • Night actions vs Day voting
  • Role reveals on death

Information Architecture:

  • Investigators gather specific info
  • Doctors/bodyguards protect
  • Serial killers/mafia kill
  • Jesters have anti-goals

Cross-Pollination:

  • Among Us mods import Town of Salem roles
  • Doctor, Jester, Sheriff mechanics adapted
  • Proves modular role design works

Key Differences#

Aspect Among Us Town of Salem
Complexity Low High
Real-time Yes No
Role count 2-4 48+
Learning curve Minutes Hours
Evidence type Visual/physical Mechanical/logical

6. Nemesis Hidden Objectives#

Semi-Cooperative Design#

Core Tension:

  • Players need to cooperate to survive
  • Each player has hidden personal objective
  • Objectives may conflict with group survival
  • Multiple winners possible

Objective System#

Two Decks:

  • Corporate Objectives
  • Personal Objectives

Selection Mechanic:

  • Each player gets 1 from each deck
  • Must choose one when first alien appears
  • Discard the other
  • Hidden until game end

Objective Types#

Examples:

  • Survive and reach specific destination
  • Be the only survivor
  • Ensure specific character dies
  • Collect certain items
  • Ship reaches specific coordinate

Design Insight:

  • Even "traitors" need group help initially
  • Late-game betrayals most effective
  • Objectives vary in difficulty
  • Some objectives compatible, some contradictory

Cooperative Mode Alternative#

Full Co-op Option:

  • Special objective deck
  • All objectives must complete
  • At least one character survives
  • Removes betrayal tension

7. Anti-Kingmaking in Social Deduction#

Kingmaking Definition#

Two Simultaneous Conditions:

  1. Player feels they've lost the game
  2. That player decides who wins

Why It Feels Bad:

  • Violates implicit fair play contract
  • "Best player" expectation broken
  • Creates meta-game grudges
  • Reduces strategic satisfaction

Mitigation Strategies#

Score Opacity:

  • Hide scores until end
  • Blur winning line
  • Create uncertainty about who's winning

Close Positioning:

  • Keep all players in contention
  • Comeback mechanisms
  • Catch-up mechanics

Interaction Strength:

  • Many small interactions > few large ones
  • Reduce individual impact
  • Distribute decision points

Rule Variations:

  • Points don't automatically transfer
  • Active gain required, not passive loss
  • Reduce zero-sum interactions

Embracing Kingmaking#

Alternative Perspective (Cole Wehrle):

  • Kingmaking creates stories
  • Manipulation, alliances, betrayal narratives
  • Social creatures naturally form alliances
  • Part of emergent gameplay

When It Works:

  • Highly interactive games
  • Short game length
  • Social/party contexts
  • When narrative > competition

Application to Weave Conspiracy#

Mitigation Approaches:

  • Hidden victory points
  • Multiple paths to victory
  • Late-game reveals change calculations
  • Personal objectives reduce pure kingmaking

8. Design Recommendations for Weave Conspiracy#

Hidden Agenda System#

Public Allegiance:

  • Visible faction assignment (Path affiliation)
  • Known abilities and resources
  • Creates baseline trust/suspicion

Hidden Agenda Types: | Agenda | Description | Win Condition | |--------|-------------|---------------| | True Believer | Loyal to faction | Faction wins | | Ambitious Usurper | Self-serving | Highest-ranked survivor | | Void Touched | Secretly corrupted | Allied casualties (hidden) | | Double Agent | Serving hidden faction | Complete secret missions | | Prophet | Prophecy-focused | Fulfill specific prophecy | | Pacifist | Peace-seeker | Prevent major battles | | Martyr | Sacrifice-seeker | Die heroically | | Collector | Resource-focused | Acquire specific items |

Information Fragmentation (Blood on Clocktower Style)#

Veil Sight Abilities:

  • Different players see different information
  • "Weave Reading" reveals partial truths
  • Multiple readings needed for full picture
  • Deception possible even in revelations

Accusation System#

Formal Accusations:

  • Cost Veil Points to accuse
  • Evidence requirements
  • Defense opportunity
  • Community vote on guilt

Consequences:

  • Guilty: Lose influence, reveal agenda
  • Innocent: Accuser loses credibility
  • Creates risk in accusations

Sleeper Agent Adaptation#

Void Corruption Progression:

  • Characters can become corrupted over time
  • Hidden corruption track
  • Triggers at certain thresholds
  • "You were good, now you're not"

Weave Connection Integration#

Relationship-Based Deduction:

  • Weave connections reveal information
  • Strong bonds create trust OR vulnerability
  • Betrayals create narrative drama
  • Connections persist across game modes

Anti-Kingmaking Measures#

Multiple Victory Conditions:

  • Faction victory
  • Personal agenda completion
  • Prophecy fulfillment
  • Survival points

Hidden Scoring:

  • True scores revealed at end
  • Mid-game uncertainty maintained
  • Reduces strategic kingmaking

Catch-Up Mechanics:

  • Suspicion reduction through good deeds
  • Redemption arcs possible
  • Late-game revelations can flip outcomes

References#

  • The Resistance: Avalon - Don Eskridge (Indie Boards & Cards)
  • Battlestar Galactica: The Board Game - Fantasy Flight Games
  • Blood on the Clocktower - Steven Medway (The Pandemonium Institute)
  • Secret Hitler - Goat, Wolf, & Cabbage LLC
  • Among Us - Innersloth
  • Town of Salem - BlankMediaGames
  • Nemesis - Adam Kwapinski (Awaken Realms)
  • "Mitigating Kingmaking in Multiplayer Board Games" - DiVA Portal
  • "King Me: A Defense of King-Making" - Cole Wehrle (GDC)
  • "Social Deduction Game Design Fundamentals" - BKGameDesign