Status: Active
Date: April 10, 2026
Owners: OSHUN Metis Engineering, OSHUN Product, OSHUN Psyche, OSHUN Yemaya, OSHUN Safety
Related:
docs/releases/v1/reports/metis-domain-gap-analysis-and-full-integration-report-2026-03-23.mddocs/releases/v1/reports/metis-subsystem-ownership-matrix.mddocs/releases/v1/reports/metis-v1-scorecard.mddocs/releases/v1/reports/metis-v1-workstream-tracking.mddocs/releases/v1/runbooks/metis-operator-workflows-runbook.mddocs/releases/v1/design/ai-disclosure-copy-guidance.mddocs/releases/v1/specs/todos.mddocs/releases/v1/domains/metis/README.mddocs/releases/v1/domains/psyche/README.mddocs/releases/v1/domains/yemaya/README.md
1. Purpose#
This document defines the canonical Metis tier split for educational teacher representations in OSHUN V1.
The split is required because Metis now spans three materially different delivery modes:
- prerecorded lecturer
- live voice tutor
- live avatar tutor
These must not be treated as cosmetic skins on one generic tutor runtime. They differ in:
- learner expectation
- latency and interruption posture
- exportability
- consent and likeness risk
- operations and rollout posture
- owning substrate
This document establishes the product-tier and runtime-tier model that all later Metis media work must follow.
2. Research Inputs Reviewed on April 10, 2026#
Current official product patterns still support the same separation identified in the March 23, 2026 Metis gap analysis:
- OpenAI Realtime API guidance recommends WebRTC for browser speech-to-speech experiences and treats realtime voice interaction as a distinct low-latency application category.
- Tavus documents conversational video as a real-time WebRTC session with a modular stack for transport, STT, LLM, TTS, and realtime replica rendering.
- HeyGen documents its streaming avatar path as a low-latency WebRTC experience, and explicitly directs new builds toward the current live avatar product line instead of older interactive-avatar naming.
- ElevenLabs documents a dedicated low-latency conversational voice stack and positions real-time voice interaction separately from batch audio generation.
- Synthesia documents dubbing, multilingual training-video generation, and SCORM-capable export as asynchronous media-delivery workflows rather than live conversational tutoring.
Inference:
- The market does not treat polished course video and real-time tutoring as one runtime.
- Live voice and live avatar products share some tutoring logic, but they do not share the same embodiment, safety, or latency envelope.
- Metis should therefore define separate product tiers and separate runtime tiers rather than hiding all three modes under a generic “AI teacher” label.
Primary sources:
- OpenAI Realtime API with WebRTC:
https://platform.openai.com/docs/guides/realtime-webrtc - Tavus Conversational Video Interface overview:
https://docs.tavus.io/sections/conversational-video-interface - Tavus Conversation overview:
https://docs.tavus.io/sections/conversational-video-interface/conversation - HeyGen Streaming API overview:
https://docs.heygen.com/docs/streaming-api - ElevenLabs Conversational AI introduction:
https://elevenlabs.io/docs/conversational-ai/docs/introduction/ - Synthesia AI Dubbing docs:
https://docs.synthesia.io/docs/video-dubbing - Synthesia video overview and SCORM export docs:
https://docs.synthesia.io/docs/video-overview
3. Core Distinction#
3.1 Product Tier#
A product tier is the learner-facing promise Metis is making.
It answers:
- what kind of experience the learner is entering
- what controls the learner expects
- whether the mode is synchronous or asynchronous
- what can be exported, replayed, resumed, or embedded
3.2 Runtime Tier#
A runtime tier is the technical execution posture required to fulfill that promise.
It answers:
- whether generation is batch or real time
- which substrate owns transport and rendering
- what latency budget class applies
- what failure and fallback policies are allowed
Rule:
- Product tiers may not be introduced without mapping to one canonical runtime tier.
- Runtime tiers may not be reused across product tiers if doing so obscures distinct safety, cost, approval, or export behavior.
4. Canonical Tier Model#
4.1 Product Tiers#
type MetisTeacherProductTier =
| 'prerecorded_lecturer'
| 'live_voice_tutor'
| 'live_avatar_tutor';
prerecorded_lecturer#
Learner promise:
- polished lesson delivery
- replayable and packageable media
- stable narration and presentation quality
- export-oriented instructional content
Primary use cases:
- lesson delivery
- multilingual lecture packs
- LMS distribution
- previewable course trailers or narrated modules
live_voice_tutor#
Learner promise:
- low-latency spoken tutoring
- interruptible back-and-forth dialogue
- office-hours style help without visual embodiment
- continuity across active study sessions
Primary use cases:
- question answering during study
- oral walkthroughs
- spoken remediation and coaching
- hands-free tutoring on mobile or desktop
live_avatar_tutor#
Learner promise:
- low-latency spoken tutoring with visible teacher embodiment
- face, gesture, lip-sync, and turn-taking coherence
- stronger presence for guided explanation, demo, or office-hours posture
Primary use cases:
- premium tutoring sessions
- guided problem solving with embodiment
- office hours or live class support
- visually anchored coaching or demonstration flows
4.2 Runtime Tiers#
type MetisTeacherRuntimeTier =
| 'rendered_media_pipeline'
| 'realtime_voice_session'
| 'realtime_avatar_session';
rendered_media_pipeline#
Execution posture:
- asynchronous or queued
- batch render oriented
- exportable and cacheable
- publication-package compatible
Primary owner:
- Yemaya for rendered asset pipelines
realtime_voice_session#
Execution posture:
- synchronous
- low-latency conversational turn-taking
- streaming transport and session state
- interruption and resume aware
Primary owner:
- Psyche realtime voice runtime
realtime_avatar_session#
Execution posture:
- synchronous
- low-latency conversational turn-taking
- embodied rendering and lip-sync
- stricter transport, GPU, and likeness controls
Primary owner:
- Psyche realtime avatar runtime
4.3 Allowed Mapping#
| Product tier | Canonical runtime tier | Reason |
|---|---|---|
prerecorded_lecturer |
rendered_media_pipeline |
lecture delivery is asset-first, replayable, and export-oriented |
live_voice_tutor |
realtime_voice_session |
tutoring is conversational but does not require embodied rendering |
live_avatar_tutor |
realtime_avatar_session |
tutoring is conversational and embodied, with avatar-specific controls |
Hard rule:
prerecorded_lecturermust not be implemented as a hidden “live avatar tutor with recording enabled.”live_voice_tutormust not be modeled as a degraded avatar session by default.live_avatar_tutormay uselive_voice_tutoras a controlled fallback, but only through explicit learner-visible disclosure and policy-aware downgrade handling.
5. Tier Requirements by Mode#
5.1 prerecorded_lecturer#
Required characteristics:
- chaptered or lesson-bound media output
- deterministic transcript, caption, and subtitle package
- reviewable script and narration artifacts
- publication and export eligibility checks
- durable provenance and rights metadata
- acceptable queue-time and batch-job posture
Not required:
- sub-second turn-taking
- interruption handling
- live session continuity
Primary dependencies:
- Metis for lesson sequencing and pedagogy intent
- Yemaya for audio, video, slide, diagram, and lecture rendering
- Themis for rights and likeness enforcement
- Sophia and Isis where grounded claims and model provenance apply
5.2 live_voice_tutor#
Required characteristics:
- active microphone and speaker session controls
- interruption-aware turn-taking
- low-latency STT, LLM, and TTS loop
- session resume, continuity, and escalation support
- transcript capture and learner-visible synthetic voice disclosure
Not required:
- visible teacher embodiment
- avatar render approval
- lip-sync or gesture coherence
Primary dependencies:
- Metis for tutoring product logic and learner context
- Psyche for realtime voice transport and orchestration
- Iris for continuity and learner preferences
- Lilith for pedagogy mode and teaching behavior
- Themis for safety, oversight, and integrity boundaries
5.3 live_avatar_tutor#
Required characteristics:
- all
live_voice_tutorrequirements - explicit avatar identity selection
- embodiment-safe animation and lip-sync
- stronger latency and degradation handling
- likeness consent, avatar-profile approval, and incident posture
Additional governance rule:
live_avatar_tutormay not ship unless the relevantAvatarTeacherProfileandVoiceLikenessConsentRecordcontracts are satisfied by the current release posture.
Primary dependencies:
- Metis for tutoring product logic and learner context
- Psyche for realtime avatar orchestration and rendering
- Iris and Lilith for continuity and pedagogy
- Themis for likeness, consent, moderation, and safety
6. Product and Runtime Rules#
6.1 Entitlement Rule#
Entitlements must be assigned at the product-tier level, not the runtime-tier level.
Reason:
- learners purchase or are granted
prerecorded_lecturer,live_voice_tutor, orlive_avatar_tutor - operators route that entitlement onto a runtime tier
6.2 Analytics Rule#
Analytics must distinguish all three product tiers even when two of them share parts of the tutoring brain.
Minimum analytics dimensions:
- product tier entered
- runtime tier invoked
- fallback or downgrade applied
- disclosure shown
- session or asset completion outcome
6.3 Review and Approval Rule#
The approval model must stay split:
- prerecorded lecturer approvals are publication and media-governance oriented
- live voice tutor approvals are pedagogy, latency, and safety oriented
- live avatar tutor approvals are pedagogy, latency, safety, likeness, and embodiment oriented
6.4 Export Rule#
Only prerecorded_lecturer is export-grade by default for LMS packaging and
asynchronous course distribution.
live_voice_tutor and live_avatar_tutor may export transcripts, summaries, or
evidence-backed artifacts, but they are not themselves lecture-export modes.
6.5 Continuity Rule#
Continuity must also stay split:
- prerecorded lecturer continuity is asset progression and resume position
- live tutor continuity is session memory, learner state, and open thread recovery
6.6 Failure and Fallback Rule#
Fallback must respect the tier model:
live_avatar_tutormay downgrade tolive_voice_tutorlive_voice_tutormay downgrade to text tutoringprerecorded_lecturershould fail into delayed render, alternate asset, or text transcript delivery, not into a surprise live session
7. Cross-Subsystem Ownership#
| Concern | Canonical owner | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| product-tier selection | Metis | the learner-facing educational promise belongs to Metis |
| rendered lecture runtime | Yemaya | narrated and polished media generation is an asset-pipeline problem |
| live voice runtime | Psyche | streaming voice transport and turn-taking are realtime-runtime responsibilities |
| live avatar runtime | Psyche | embodiment, rendering, and live avatar transport are realtime-runtime responsibilities |
| pedagogy policy across all tiers | Lilith | teaching behavior should not fork by renderer without pedagogy ownership |
| continuity and learner prefs | Iris | session memory and learner preference persistence remain cross-tier concerns |
| rights, consent, and misuse | Themis | likeness, safety, and consent authority cannot live only in product code |
Ownership rule:
- Metis owns the choice of tier exposed to the learner.
- Metis does not own a separate local realtime runtime for voice or avatar.
- Metis does not own a separate local batch-render pipeline for polished media.
8. Delivery Sequence for the Remaining Backlog#
This tier model sets the required execution order for the remaining media tasks:
V1-MET-088implementsprerecorded_lectureronrendered_media_pipelineV1-MET-089implementslive_voice_tutoronrealtime_voice_sessionV1-MET-090formalizesAvatarTeacherProfileandVoiceLikenessConsentRecordV1-MET-092adds controlled fallback from avatar to voice to textV1-MET-093deepens real-time tutor session behavior through PsycheV1-MET-094deepens lecture asset generation through Yemaya
Sequencing rule:
- Metis may ship
prerecorded_lecturerandlive_voice_tutorbeforelive_avatar_tutorreaches launch grade. live_avatar_tutormust never be the prerequisite for all media work.
9. Canonical Exit Criteria for This Tier Definition#
V1-MET-087 is complete only if all of the following are true:
- the three learner-visible teacher modes are explicitly named and distinct
- each mode maps to exactly one canonical runtime tier
- export, entitlement, analytics, review, and fallback rules differ by tier
- ownership boundaries align with Metis, Psyche, Yemaya, Iris, Lilith, and Themis responsibilities already established elsewhere in OSHUN V1 docs
That condition is now satisfied by this document.