# OSHUN Studio Accessibility Governance Journeys and Edge Cases

Status: Active  
Owner: OSHUN Studio Architecture + OSHUN Web + Platform SRE + OSHUN Security +
Compliance  
Last Updated: 2026-02-23  
Related:

- `docs/adr/ADR-0044-oshun-studio-accessibility-governance.md`
- `docs/releases/v1/specs/studio-accessibility-governance-dependency-and-data-contract-map.md`

## Purpose

Define primary journeys and deterministic edge-case behavior for Studio
accessibility governance workflows.

This document is the execution artifact for `OST-00251`.

## Personas

- Collaboration Lead
- Program Operator
- Accessibility Reviewer
- Security Reviewer
- Compliance Auditor

## Journey Principles

1. Accessibility checks must be continuous and contract-backed.
2. Violations must map to deterministic severity and ownership.
3. Waiver and release decisions must enforce policy-tier controls.
4. Remediation closure requires post-fix validation evidence.

## 1. Primary Journeys

### J1. Define and Publish Accessibility Contract

**Goal**: Create/update canonical accessibility requirements for governed
workflows.

**Entry**: `Accessibility governance workspace`

**Steps**:

1. Select domain, workflow, scope (`keyboard`, `screen_reader`, `semantic`,
   `motion`, `contrast`).
2. Define severity classification and release-channel scope.
3. Bind owner and expiry metadata.
4. Publish versioned contract definition.
5. Emit contract-definition audit evidence.

**Success State**:

- Contract is valid, attributed, and ready for validation enforcement.

### J2. Execute Accessibility Validation Suites

**Goal**: Run CI/runtime accessibility checks and derive deterministic posture.

**Entry**: `Release candidate or runtime monitoring cycle`

**Steps**:

1. Run axe/keyboard/screen-reader suite set.
2. Aggregate pass/warning/fail verdict by contract/workflow.
3. Persist validation artifacts and violation metadata.
4. Trigger release block on critical violations.
5. Emit validation result telemetry and audit events.

**Success State**:

- Validation posture is deterministic and release-gate consumable.

### J3. Triage Accessibility Issue and Ownership

**Goal**: Convert failing validations into actionable incident/issue records.

**Entry**: `Validation failure with violation details`

**Steps**:

1. Create accessibility issue record with severity/category.
2. Assign owner and target remediation window.
3. Link issue to contract and workflow references.
4. Classify release impact and block state.
5. Emit issue-opened governance event.

**Success State**:

- Issue is attributable, prioritized, and operationally actionable.

### J4. Decide Waiver or Release Block

**Goal**: Apply governance controls when violations persist near release.

**Entry**: `Open issue requiring release decision`

**Steps**:

1. Evaluate severity, scope, and affected release channel.
2. Validate role/tier/CAB requirements.
3. Choose waiver create/extend/revoke or release block action.
4. Persist decision and reason codes.
5. Emit policy decision audit event.

**Success State**:

- Decision is policy-compliant, auditable, and deterministic.

### J5. Execute Remediation and Close Issue

**Goal**: Implement fix and close accessibility issue with evidence.

**Entry**: `Approved remediation plan`

**Steps**:

1. Execute remediation (`fix_forward`, `rollback`, `feature_disable`).
2. Re-run affected accessibility validations.
3. Confirm violations resolved and release posture updated.
4. Close issue and unblock release where appropriate.
5. Emit remediation/closure events with validation references.

**Success State**:

- Issue closes only after verified accessibility recovery.

## 2. Critical Edge Cases

### E1. Contract Definition Missing Expiry

- Trigger: contract submitted without `expiresAt`.
- Required behavior: reject publish and require expiry metadata.

### E2. Unknown Accessibility Scope

- Trigger: contract scope not in canonical enum set.
- Required behavior: reject contract with deterministic schema error.

### E3. Duplicate Contract Key Collision

- Trigger: active contract key reused for same workflow.
- Required behavior: hard reject and return conflict semantics.

### E4. Validation Artifact Missing

- Trigger: validation verdict emitted without artifact reference.
- Required behavior: mark verdict incomplete and deny release promotion.

### E5. Critical Violation Misclassified as Warning

- Trigger: critical issue arrives with warning severity.
- Required behavior: auto-upgrade severity and emit classification incident.

### E6. Issue Without Owner

- Trigger: issue record persisted with no owner attribution.
- Required behavior: block issue progression until ownership is assigned.

### E7. Role/Tier Mismatch on Waiver Action

- Trigger: actor requests waiver with unauthorized permission tier.
- Required behavior: deny action and emit policy-denial audit event.

### E8. Production Waiver Without CAB Ticket

- Trigger: production waiver action missing approval evidence.
- Required behavior: hard deny waiver and require CAB reference.

### E9. Closure Attempt Without Revalidation

- Trigger: issue closure requested before post-fix validation pass.
- Required behavior: deny closure and require validation evidence.

### E10. Runtime Probe Failure During Incident

- Trigger: runtime accessibility probe unavailable during active issue.
- Required behavior: maintain blocked posture and escalate monitoring incident.

## 3. Journey-to-Surface Mapping

| Journey                           | Primary Surface                | Supporting Surfaces                              |
| --------------------------------- | ------------------------------ | ------------------------------------------------ |
| J1 Define/Publish Contract        | Accessibility governance panel | Contract registry + metadata controls            |
| J2 Execute Validation Suites      | Validation execution panel     | Axe/keyboard/screen-reader test pipelines        |
| J3 Triage Issue and Ownership     | Issue triage panel             | Incident routing + domain ownership matrix       |
| J4 Decide Waiver or Release Block | Policy decision panel          | RBAC/tier policy engine + CAB governance         |
| J5 Execute Remediation and Close  | Remediation closure panel      | Post-fix validation + release-gate orchestration |

## 4. Instrumentation Requirements

Required events:

- `accessibility_governance.journey.started`
- `accessibility_governance.journey.step.completed`
- `accessibility_governance.journey.blocked`
- `accessibility_governance.journey.recovered`
- `accessibility_governance.journey.completed`

Required dimensions:

- `contractId`, `contractKey`, `scope`, `severity`, `sourceDomain`
- `issueId`, `validationSource`, `violationCount`, `criticalViolationCount`
- `actorId`, `actorRole`, `workspaceId`, `permissionTier`, `releaseChannel`
- `approvalTicketRef`, `journeyId`, `stepId`, `outcome`, `latencyMs`,
  `reasonCode`

## 5. Acceptance Criteria (OST-00251)

`OST-00251` is complete only when:

1. At least five accessibility-governance journeys are documented.
2. At least ten deterministic edge cases are documented.
3. Journey-to-surface mapping is explicit.
4. Instrumentation requirements and dimensions are documented.
