# OSHUN Studio Audit and Compliance Surfaces Journeys and Edge Cases

Status: Active  
Owner: OSHUN Studio Architecture + OSHUN Security + Compliance + OSHUN Web +
OSHUN BFF  
Last Updated: 2026-02-23  
Related:

- `docs/adr/ADR-0029-oshun-studio-audit-and-compliance-surfaces.md`
- `docs/releases/v1/specs/studio-audit-and-compliance-surfaces-dependency-and-data-contract-map.md`

## Purpose

Define primary journeys and deterministic edge-case behavior for Studio audit
and compliance surfaces governance.

This document is the execution artifact for `OST-00131`.

## Personas

- Program Operator
- Security Reviewer
- Compliance Auditor
- Reliability Engineer
- Domain Integrator

## Journey Principles

1. Audit evidence must be searchable, immutable, and trace-correlated.
2. Compliance review actions must be explicit and attributable.
3. Evidence gaps must fail safe with clear remediation guidance.
4. Retention and exception workflows must remain policy-consistent.

## 1. Primary Journeys

### J1. Audit Evidence Search and Correlation

**Goal**: Locate and correlate actor/action evidence across Studio domains.

**Entry**: `Studio -> Audit and Compliance Surfaces -> Evidence Search`

**Steps**:

1. Apply filters (actor, action, domain, timeframe, outcome).
2. Retrieve paginated canonical evidence records.
3. Correlate events by trace id.
4. Inspect ordered event lineage.
5. Save investigation snapshot.

**Success State**:

- Operator can deterministically trace a governance action end to end.

### J2. Compliance Review and Attestation

**Goal**: Execute compliance review on selected evidence set.

**Entry**: `Compliance review queue`

**Steps**:

1. Select review case and linked evidence records.
2. Validate policy compliance requirements.
3. Add reviewer notes and attestation decision.
4. Approve/deny/close review case.
5. Emit compliance review audit event.

**Success State**:

- Compliance decision is recorded with full evidence linkage.

### J3. Exception Workflow and Decision Logging

**Goal**: Process compliance exceptions with transparent decisioning.

**Entry**: `Exception request submitted`

**Steps**:

1. Load exception request details and policy references.
2. Validate justification and impact scope.
3. Approve/deny exception with reason.
4. Apply decision state and expiry metadata.
5. Record exception decision evidence.

**Success State**:

- Exception decisions are policy-consistent and auditable.

### J4. Incident Audit Reconstruction

**Goal**: Reconstruct incident timeline using audit evidence.

**Entry**: `Incident alert with trace references`

**Steps**:

1. Load incident trace and related evidence chain.
2. Reconstruct actor/action sequence.
3. Identify policy denies, overrides, and failures.
4. Export evidence summary for incident response.
5. Publish remediation follow-up tasks.

**Success State**:

- Incident timeline is reconstructed with deterministic evidence integrity.

### J5. Retention Policy Verification and Legal Hold Review

**Goal**: Validate evidence retention and legal hold handling.

**Entry**: `Retention policy review cycle`

**Steps**:

1. Inspect retention policies by evidence category.
2. Verify archive tier and retention window compliance.
3. Validate legal hold flags for active investigations.
4. Confirm eligible records are archived/retained correctly.
5. Record retention verification outcome.

**Success State**:

- Retention and legal hold workflows are policy-compliant and verifiable.

## 2. Critical Edge Cases

### E1. Missing Canonical Evidence Fields

- Trigger: evidence record missing actor/action/outcome fields.
- Required behavior: reject record and raise ingestion integrity alert.

### E2. Trace Correlation Break

- Trigger: events in same trace have missing linkage.
- Required behavior: mark trace degraded and request reconciliation.

### E3. Query Filter Drift

- Trigger: query filters return nondeterministic results for same criteria.
- Required behavior: block report export and escalate data integrity issue.

### E4. Unauthorized Compliance Review Action

- Trigger: actor without review permission attempts case decision.
- Required behavior: deny action and preserve case state.

### E5. Exception Decision Without Reason

- Trigger: exception approved/denied without rationale.
- Required behavior: block decision until reason is provided.

### E6. Review Closure Without Evidence Linkage

- Trigger: review case closure lacks valid evidence references.
- Required behavior: deny closure and require evidence linkage.

### E7. Retention Window Misconfiguration

- Trigger: retention days violate policy baseline.
- Required behavior: block policy publish and escalate compliance review.

### E8. Legal Hold Conflict

- Trigger: record marked for purge while legal hold is active.
- Required behavior: block purge and raise compliance incident.

### E9. Telemetry/Audit Emission Failure

- Trigger: audit/compliance events fail to emit.
- Required behavior: buffer/retry and surface degraded observability warning.

### E10. Missing Rollback Reference for Compliance Release

- Trigger: compliance-surface release lacks certified rollback contract.
- Required behavior: block production promotion.

## 3. Journey-to-Surface Mapping

| Journey                                                | Primary Surface               | Supporting Surfaces              |
| ------------------------------------------------------ | ----------------------------- | -------------------------------- |
| J1 Audit Evidence Search and Correlation               | Audit and Compliance Surfaces | Data platform                    |
| J2 Compliance Review and Attestation                   | Audit and Compliance Surfaces | Compliance workflows             |
| J3 Exception Workflow and Decision Logging             | Audit and Compliance Surfaces | Policy governance                |
| J4 Incident Audit Reconstruction                       | Audit and Compliance Surfaces | Observability, Incident response |
| J5 Retention Policy Verification and Legal Hold Review | Audit and Compliance Surfaces | Compliance + Legal               |

## 4. Instrumentation Requirements

Required events:

- `audit_compliance.journey.started`
- `audit_compliance.journey.step.completed`
- `audit_compliance.journey.blocked`
- `audit_compliance.journey.recovered`
- `audit_compliance.journey.completed`

Required dimensions:

- `actorId`, `actorRole`, `reviewId`
- `journeyId`, `stepId`, `traceId`, `exceptionId`
- `outcome`, `latencyMs`, `errorCode`

## 5. Acceptance Criteria (OST-00131)

`OST-00131` is complete only when:

1. At least five audit/compliance journeys are documented.
2. At least ten deterministic edge cases are documented.
3. Journey-to-surface mapping is explicit.
4. Instrumentation requirements and dimensions are documented.
