# OSHUN Studio Security Hardening Program Journeys and Edge Cases

Status: Active  
Owner: OSHUN Studio Architecture + OSHUN Security Engineering + OSHUN BFF +
OSHUN Web + Platform SRE + OSHUN Data/Analytics Engineering  
Last Updated: 2026-02-23  
Related:

- `docs/adr/ADR-0049-oshun-studio-security-hardening-program.md`
- `docs/releases/v1/specs/studio-security-hardening-program-dependency-and-data-contract-map.md`

## Purpose

Define primary journeys and deterministic edge-case behavior for Studio security
hardening workflows.

This document is the execution artifact for `OST-00291`.

## Personas

- Security Operator
- Platform SRE Incident Commander
- Release Manager
- Compliance Auditor
- Domain Integration Engineer

## Journey Principles

1. Security controls must fail closed for invalid identity, trust, or policy
   context.
2. Authorization and entitlement decisions must be reason-coded and auditable.
3. Runtime trust controls (device integrity + abuse limits) must be
   deterministic.
4. High-risk production controls require explicit governance and evidence.

## 1. Primary Journeys

### J1. Validate Identity and Domain Authorization Context

**Goal**: Ensure requests are authenticated and scoped before any privileged
Studio action.

**Entry**: `Security hardening workspace`

**Steps**:

1. Ingest bearer token and parse identity/session context.
2. Validate token structure, expiration, and scope claims.
3. Evaluate domain-scope authorization for target workflow/domain.
4. Emit allow/deny authorization decision with reason code.
5. Attach audit evidence to request trace context.

**Success State**:

- Only authenticated and properly scoped requests proceed to downstream actions.

### J2. Enforce Runtime Trust and Abuse Controls

**Goal**: Protect high-risk routes from compromised or abusive requests.

**Entry**: `High-risk route invocation`

**Steps**:

1. Validate device integrity status, platform, and attestation freshness.
2. Evaluate per-route abuse/rate-limiting window and thresholds.
3. Deny compromised/stale integrity requests with reason codes.
4. Apply deterministic retry-after behavior for rate-limited requests.
5. Emit runtime trust and abuse-protection telemetry/audit events.

**Success State**:

- High-risk endpoints enforce trust and abuse controls deterministically.

### J3. Decide Sensitive Security Policy Action

**Goal**: Govern privileged security actions (hardening mode changes,
exceptions, emergency bypasses) through explicit policy controls.

**Entry**: `Sensitive hardening action request`

**Steps**:

1. Evaluate actor role, permission tier, and release-channel scope.
2. Validate production approval prerequisites where required.
3. Allow or deny action with explicit reason code.
4. Persist policy decision evidence for compliance.
5. Emit security policy decision audit event.

**Success State**:

- Sensitive hardening actions are policy-compliant and audit-ready.

### J4. Execute Transport Security and Pinning Transition

**Goal**: Transition transport security modes safely from report-only to
enforcement.

**Entry**: `Transport policy change request`

**Steps**:

1. Validate HTTPS and host allowlist policy prerequisites.
2. Validate pin-set completeness and verifier availability.
3. Run report-only validation window for mismatch telemetry.
4. Promote to enforce mode once acceptance thresholds are met.
5. Emit transport transition evidence and rollback metadata.

**Success State**:

- Transport hardening transitions preserve service reliability and security
  guarantees.

### J5. Recover Security Hardening Incident and Close

**Goal**: Restore healthy security posture after control failures or
regressions.

**Entry**: `Open hardening incident`

**Steps**:

1. Correlate identity, authorization, integrity, abuse, and transport signals.
2. Apply mitigation (policy rollback, threshold tuning, verifier patch, route
   guard updates).
3. Re-run hardening validation suite and confirm deny/allow behavior.
4. Verify telemetry/audit continuity restoration.
5. Close incident with post-recovery evidence bundle.

**Success State**:

- Security posture is restored with validated controls and complete evidence.

## 2. Critical Edge Cases

### E1. Missing Bearer Token

- Trigger: protected request has no bearer token.
- Required behavior: return `401` with `missing_bearer_token`.

### E2. Invalid Token Encoding

- Trigger: bearer token cannot be parsed or decoded.
- Required behavior: return `401` with `invalid_token`.

### E3. Expired Token

- Trigger: token expiration is in the past.
- Required behavior: return `401` with `expired_token`.

### E4. Domain Scope Missing

- Trigger: actor lacks `domain:*` or `domain:{target}` scope.
- Required behavior: return `403` with `domain_scope_missing`.

### E5. Entitlement Tier Insufficient

- Trigger: entitlement evaluation fails required tier.
- Required behavior: return `403` with required/effective tier metadata.

### E6. Device Attestation Missing or Stale

- Trigger: attestation timestamp missing/invalid or outside freshness window.
- Required behavior: return `403` with integrity reason code.

### E7. Invalid Device Platform

- Trigger: unknown or missing platform for high-risk endpoint.
- Required behavior: hard deny with `invalid_platform`.

### E8. Abuse Rate Limit Exceeded

- Trigger: request count exceeds configured threshold in active window.
- Required behavior: return `429` with deterministic `retry-after`.

### E9. Pinning Enforce Mode Without Verifier

- Trigger: pinning mode set to enforce without verifier implementation.
- Required behavior: block request and emit transport error telemetry.

### E10. Telemetry/Audit Sink Degradation

- Trigger: security decision executes but audit/telemetry persistence fails.
- Required behavior: mark degraded-observability state and block production
  hardening promotions.

## 3. Journey-to-Surface Mapping

| Journey                              | Primary Surface                  | Supporting Surfaces                                     |
| ------------------------------------ | -------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------- |
| J1 Identity + Domain Authorization   | Security hardening control panel | Authz middleware + scope/entitlement evaluators         |
| J2 Runtime Trust + Abuse Enforcement | Runtime trust panel              | Device integrity middleware + abuse protection controls |
| J3 Sensitive Policy Decision         | Security policy decision panel   | RBAC/tier engine + approval governance                  |
| J4 Transport and Pinning Transition  | Transport security panel         | Pinning verifier + policy configuration registry        |
| J5 Hardening Incident Recovery       | Security incident recovery panel | Dashboards + runbook orchestration + remediation tools  |

## 4. Instrumentation Requirements

Required events:

- `security_hardening.journey.started`
- `security_hardening.journey.step.completed`
- `security_hardening.journey.blocked`
- `security_hardening.journey.rate_limited`
- `security_hardening.journey.recovered`
- `security_hardening.journey.completed`

Required dimensions:

- `actorId`, `actorRole`, `permissionTier`, `releaseChannel`
- `domain`, `requestId`, `traceId`, `sessionId`, `scope`
- `integrityStatus`, `platform`, `attestedAt`, `maxAgeMs`
- `windowMs`, `maxRequests`, `retryAfterSeconds`, `rateLimited`
- `pinningMode`, `hostname`, `verifierConfigured`, `matchedPins`
- `journeyId`, `stepId`, `outcome`, `reasonCode`, `latencyMs`

## 5. Acceptance Criteria (OST-00291)

`OST-00291` is complete only when:

1. At least five security hardening journeys are documented.
2. At least ten deterministic edge cases are documented.
3. Journey-to-surface mapping is explicit.
4. Instrumentation requirements and dimensions are documented.
