# V1-003 — V1 reference-vertical level-4 evidence

Status: **blocked on a fresh live provider/operator/evaluation/canary run; none
of the six acceptance checks is closed**.

Evidence-contract source tip: `df17d74948d2d2428f83797609f96a10587d2905`.

## Evidence boundary

The repository now has one machine-verifiable, fail-closed contract for the
entire V1 reference vertical:

- `scripts/v1/verify-reference-vertical-evidence.mjs`
- `evidence/v1-v9/V1-003-reference-vertical-evidence.json`
- `evidence/v1-v9/V1-003-reference-vertical-readiness.json`

The contract requires all six acceptance dimensions to pass together:

1. A bounded set of unique text, image, audio, and video slots must be covered
   exactly once by real provider-backed artifacts. Every artifact must carry a
   provider request receipt, model identity, content hash, locator, rights
   record, and lineage.
2. Authenticated UI receipts must show pause, edit, replace, approve, and
   rollback each executing once.
3. Judge calibration must use at least 100 licensed human-gold samples and at
   least two distinct provider judges, with positive normalized weights,
   measured disagreement, and a calibration report.
4. Every outcome must attribute to an exact generated artifact, and the primary
   optimization objective must be an explicit human outcome rather than raw
   engagement.
5. A signed A/B or champion/challenger result against the authored baseline must
   have at least 100 samples per arm, an effect estimate, a p-value, and a
   verdict.
6. The same run must have an observed canary placement, cohort, SLOs, costs, and
   an executed, verified rollback drill.

Completed evidence is fresh for no more than 24 hours. Missing, malformed,
duplicated, stale, simulated, or incomplete evidence blocks the gate.

## Current retained report

The retained evidence input identifies the run as
`v1-reference-vertical-not-yet-executed`. Its readiness report is `blocked`,
with all six checks false. It does not substitute fixtures, mocks, or repository
capability claims for live proof.

The current execution environment exposed no live provider credential variable
names in a name-only environment scan, and the retained audit registry has no
current provider-probe artifact. The environment also cannot manufacture the
licensed human-gold set, authenticated operator actions, controlled live
experiment, production canary observations, or rollback drill required by this
contract. Those are external execution inputs, so the V1-003 checklist remains
open.

## Verification

On 2026-07-27:

- `node --check scripts/v1/verify-reference-vertical-evidence.mjs` passed.
- `node --test scripts/v1/verify-reference-vertical-evidence.test.mjs` passed
  9/9, including the valid reference case and adversarial cases for fake or
  missing providers, malformed slot bounds, duplicate artifacts, incomplete
  operator flow, invalid judge panels, engagement optimization, undersampled
  comparison, missing rollback, and stale evidence.
- The default CLI rejected the retained blocked evidence with a nonzero exit.
- `--report` reproduced
  `evidence/v1-v9/V1-003-reference-vertical-readiness.json` byte-for-byte after
  formatting.
- Prettier, ESLint, `node --check`, and `git diff --check` passed.

## Unblock procedure

Execute one bounded live run with authorized provider credentials and licensed
evaluation data, capture immutable receipts from the operator UI, experiment,
canary, SLO/cost telemetry, and rollback drill, then replace the empty `run`
payload in `V1-003-reference-vertical-evidence.json`. Run:

```sh
node scripts/v1/verify-reference-vertical-evidence.mjs \
  --evidence=evidence/v1-v9/V1-003-reference-vertical-evidence.json \
  --report
```

Only a report with `status: "passed"` and all six checks true is sufficient to
close the corresponding checklist items.
