# Power Dynamics Awareness

> Philosophical doc 32.16.3.11.

## Why power matters to moderation

The same words mean different things depending on who says them to whom. "I know
where you live" between equals is a creepy joke; from a stranger to a performer
it is a threat. A pile-on of a thousand on one is not the same speech act as one
person disagreeing with another. **Identical content can carry opposite moral
weight depending on the power relationship around it.** A moderation system
blind to power will systematically protect the powerful and punish the
vulnerable — treating a victim's angry response the same as the aggression that
provoked it.

## Power-aware design

Kuan Yin reads power, not just words:

- **Power-dynamic detection** (`precognition.detectPowerDynamic`) assesses the
  direction of power between author and target (author-over-target,
  target-over-author, balanced) and weights harm accordingly.
- **Asymmetry of numbers** — cascade and dogpile prediction
  (`cascade-prediction`) recognises that many-against-one is a distinct harm,
  not just many individual messages.
- **Structural vulnerability** — `determineProtectionLevel` and
  `assessTargetVulnerability` weight minors, performers, and the recently-
  targeted toward stronger protection, because exposure isn't equally
  distributed.
- **Facilitator vigilance** — in restorative circles, facilitators actively
  rebalance so the more powerful party can't dominate the process.

## The bias trap

Power-blindness produces a specific, well-documented failure: marginalised users
are over-moderated (their anger at mistreatment is "toxic") while the better-
resourced learn to harm within the rules. Kuan Yin treats this as a fairness
requirement, not a nicety — the evaluation suite checks for exactly this
disparity across demographics and cultures, and a model that reproduces it
doesn't ship (see [Ethical Framework](10-ethical-framework.md)).

## Punching up, punching down

The framework does not pretend all conflict is symmetric. Protecting a powerful
target from a vulnerable critic, and protecting a vulnerable target from a
powerful aggressor, are _not_ the same act even if the words rhyme. Reading the
power around the words is how Kuan Yin tells them apart — and refuses to launder
the abuse of power as "just enforcing the rules equally."
