Eve library

Visual integrity faults, measured (2026-09-10)

Guide

Revision 1

On this page

Evidence for 182.C.19.04: face merging, identity swaps, duplicate people, flicker, sudden age/skin-tone shifts, and a speaker inheriting another person's mouth or voice.

Real face crops from the committed frame ../2026-09-10-openrouter-face-detection/two-foreground-subjects-plus-bystanders.png, alpha-blended, duplicated, blurred and tone-shifted, all measured with YuNet detection and SFace embeddings.

The finding that matters most is not one of the six#

Blur destroys identity long before it destroys detection.

Gaussian σ detected? confidence cosine against its own unblurred self
0 yes 0.938 0.866
4 yes 0.922 0.453
8 yes 0.879 0.033 — random
12 yes 0.792 −0.103 — negatively correlated
16 no — —

At σ=8 the detector is 0.879 confident there is a face, and that face's embedding has collapsed to noise. A pipeline that gates on detection score will feed noise into identity comparison and get a confident wrong answer. assertEmbeddingUsable runs before any of the six detections, because every one of them reads an embedding.

The signatures#

Face merging#

alpha cos(A) cos(B) margin
0.00 0.882 0.251 0.631
0.25 0.688 0.238 0.450
0.50 0.341 0.320 0.021
0.75 0.257 0.703 0.446
1.00 0.210 0.828 0.618

A 50/50 blend of two real faces embeds as neither person, and equally unlike both. The signature is a low best cosine and a near-zero margin — both, in conjunction. A low cosine alone is an unknown face; a small margin alone is two strangers who look alike.

Duplicate people#

The same crop twice in one frame gives two simultaneous detections at mutual cosine 0.9565; two different people side by side give 0.3243. Simultaneity is what makes it a fault: the same person across two frames is the point of tracking, and the same person twice in one frame is impossible.

Flicker#

Reproduced at the detection boundary — blur alternating σ 12 (detected, 0.792 confident) and σ 16 (not detected) flipped presence on 11 of 11 transitions.

It did not reproduce by size: YuNet held a detection down to a 16-pixel face and never dropped one oscillating between 56- and 40-pixel patches. So flicker here is a marginal-quality phenomenon, not a marginal-size one.

Sudden skin-tone shift#

An ITA move of +40.9° under constant lighting left the identity cosine at 0.954. SFace is essentially blind to skin tone, so an identity check will not catch a tone change. They are independent detections and both are needed — and a tone comparison across mismatched lighting is refused, because 182.C.19.02 measured a one-stop exposure change moving a subject 58.2°.

Identity swaps#

Measured under 182.C.19.03: occlusion swapped a track onto the other person twice. See ../2026-09-10-identity-tracking/.

A speaker inheriting another person's mouth or voice#

Split, honestly. The mouth half is measurable and already built — human-video-speaker-binding.ts (182.C.17) binds speech runs to mouth motion and detects a face moving its mouth while somebody else speaks. The voice half needs speaker embeddings or diarisation, which is not staged on this box, so it is reported as not-measured rather than approximated.

Not measured at all#

Fault Why
age shift No age model is staged; 182.C.19.02 records why a number would be worse than none.
inherited voice Needs speaker embeddings or diarisation. The mouth half is covered; the voice half is not.

Both travel in the report rather than in a comment, because a report listing clean detections reads as clean whether or not two more were never attempted.

Per-item status this evidence supports#

Item Was Is
182.C.19.04 not-started done for five of six; age shift and the voice half of the sixth are not measured
182.C.19.08 pending a fourth reason a universal cutoff cannot work: image quality moves the cosine to noise